The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 3 · March 1905
100printed page
scan 18 of 52

word—or whether we shall gradually, but surely, drift and perish. To-day we are at the meeting of the ways: we have to choose. A people has seldom been brought face to face with a larger problem, no more serious one has ever tried Jewry. We have to devise means for bringing together in a cohesive union of purpose, of ultimate aim, our scattered people. We have to unite many diverse interests, many varying aspirations around the national ideal which springs from our unfailing faith in the immense potentiality of our people. To-day Jewry is bound together by a narrow bond of sympathy—a bond that day by day is weakening, and that, in a little while, may fail. In adhesion to the national ideal is Jewry's hope, and to the spread of that as a cult, irrespective of measures and of men, must Zionists devote themselves. There is no short cut to the re-establishment of Jewry as a nation: its natural work will begin and will end in the hearts and the souls of its people. I have heard Zionists declare their opinion that if we were successful in obtaining a charter from the Ottoman Government for Palestine, or even a part of it, all Jews would at once turn Zionists. I do not believe it. I believe, in any case, this would be puting the cart before the horse. Let us infuse our people first with courage and resolution, and a determination to make personal sacrifice for the sake of saving our people as a nation: until we have this spirit with us largely pervading Jewry, we shall be building on the sand, and any charter we obtain will be not worth the parchment upon which its terms are recorded. To be sure, Zionists have, in many instances, shown themselves capable of rising to heights of self-abandonment and sacrifice which have been a revelation to Jews. It is in this good foundation-work we must persevere—we must be

missioners of Jewish Nationalism as a great eternal principle. We may rely upon it that our best hope of ultimate success is in the numbers we can convert to the great and grand ideal to which we have declared our unswerving allegiance.

And this does not admit, by any means, of a shirking of opportunities that present themselves, and it is just because I see in many quarters both within and without Zionist ranks, a disposition to shirk the opportunity that East Africa presents to us, that I venture to doubt whether we have sufficiently impressed upon Jewry our ideals, or whether we ourselves have yet become sufficiently impressed with them.

Nor do I wish for an instant to imply that we should not push forward with unceasing zeal our work in Palestine. I rejoice to see that some of our friends at Wilna have, at a Conference there, decided to urge the formation of a special committee which shall proceed to Palestine, and there organize our people upon national lines. In proper hands and within certain limits, this seems to me to be the sort of work upon which Zionists should engage, and a departure which may yield good fruit. It appears to me to be more hopeful than the policy of acquiring interests in land, and otherwise, in Palestine, while yet we have secured no political rights in that country.

But I have long been of opinion that, so far as Palestine is concerned, the energies of Zionists should be devoted to securing there a much larger Jewish population than at present. It seems to me only reasonable to say that, whatever may be our moral and sentimental right to the land, we can have no practical right to it so long as Jews do not form at least a considerable majority of its indwellers. And this brings me to say that Zionist activity