The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 3 · March 1905
98printed page
scan 16 of 52

be there amidst conditions infinitely more desirable than those which surround them in Eastern Europe, or in the slums of Great Britain and the United States. To that settlement they would be welcomed: this, at least, would be a novelty for the migrating Jew.

Now, a strong objection to the East African plan is that it concedes Jewish autonomy, and I will say at once that for those who care to regard Jews as merely a religious sect,—whose notions of Jewry are so parochial that they are afraid to think of it as a nation, and whose ideas of religion are so cramped that they imagine it only as something closely environed by formulas and creeds—that for those the objection is tenable. I can quite understand persons with these paltry ideals content to see Jews suffer and become more and more debased, rather than aid in any attempts to save them as a people. But I would be sorry, indeed, to think that the great bulk and body of our people are sunk so low, or that of the patriotism which Jews exhibit with Eastern lavishness for every nation amongst whom they live they have none left for their own people.

This autonomy bogey of which so much has been sought to be made is, however, by no means a formidable monster. All that is proposed is that the territory should be under an administration of Jews appointed by, or approved by, the British Government. Dr. Herzl insisted upon that point because such an autonomy is the only natural means whereby the large territory can become, and remain, specifically Jewish. It is the only possible, practical guarantee, for it would certainly be ridiculous to expect the British Government to be party to any plan whereby the exclusion of non-Jews from a territory under the control of the Crown should be a definite regulation. Nor can it be sup-

posed that any other means would be so easy for introducing regulations or laws which a Jewish population would need. I give only one instance, an important one—the legal day of rest. Under the contemplated autonomy that would, of course, be the Sabbath. Can it not be seen of what immense value this would be in, to go no further, the physical regeneration of our people? But the one thing essential in the proposal is to make the territory attractive to Jews, and in autonomy we have the best means. The Argentine Colonies failed because there was no point of sentimental attraction for Jews. Autonomy will supply it in East Africa. We ought not to establish a merely glorified ghetto there—a place to which Jews should be more or less compelled. We ought to establish there a settlement which should attract Jews for other than, as well as for, material reason. If we were establishing small colonies—estates—of Jews, the matter might be different, but here we are seeking to set up a large settlement, a place about half the size of Palestine—for such a settlement autonomy is essential. Unless we are to have autonomy in East Africa, the whole plan is, to a large extent, superfluous. For there is room for, I know not how many, more Jewish colonists in Argentine, and elsewhere, if the question were only a matter of space and opportunity. But autonomy even outside Palestine would infuse in those who migrated to East Africa, and still more in those who were born there, the practical beginnings of a Jewish consciousness, and this sense of relationship with something Jewish in the larger sense, would in its turn, make for a rightful independence of feeling and an abiding interest in the territory. There is, however, a reason for a Jewish autonomy in the proposed settlement in East Africa, which