of the countries of their birth, and to slacken its hold on the religious adhesion of congregants who came under the influence of general culture. The synagogue, aided by exclusion and persecution of Jews, was for ages the one potent force in preventing assimilation of Jews among the nations of the earth—assimilation, that is, in thought, in spirit, in identity of human interests. To-day the synagogue, as such a force, is weak everywhere, and is day by day growing weaker. Even in countries of persecution “culture” is beating the synagogue, and the young Jew of the Pale is often as unobservant as— and has far less respect for orthodox observances than—the young Jew of the West. There is no necessity for me here to labor this point. Zionists are agreed that the Jewish question is urgent. But some imagine they are justified in the indolent laissez faire they have so strongly condemned in others, just because they have proclaimed Zionist principles. Having asserted them, they deem their duty done, and because they have fixed, and rightly, their minds on Zion, are content to let things take their course until Zion is theirs, ignoring the real objects for which we need Zion and the other work that preliminarily is necessary or, at least, can be highly assistant. In truth, the laissez faire in them is but a long step removed from that which afflicts their opponents. When we who refuse to regard with equanimity the state of Jewry, when we who refuse to fold our hands and wait for Zion, express anxiety, they deride us and declare us lacking in faith—there are God’s promises, they say, and the prophecies. But it occurs to me that in every case where it has been shown with scientific accuracy that prophecies have been realized, the work of man has been an important, an essential, element.
If, however, Zionists cannot rightly hold aloof from the East Africa proposal—if upon them rests the rightful responsibility of seeing that the proposal does not fail by reason of disregard of its immense importance—I contend that there are limitations to the activity in connection with it that should be demanded of them. The funds at our disposal are none too large, and they must be jealously guarded until we are enabled to use them for legitimate work in Palestine. And this applies also to the time and energy which the Zionist organization as a body ought to be called upon to expend upon any scheme, however, important, outside Palestine. Some of our opponents have constantly asserted that they sympathize with our ideals—that they applaud our aims, but that Palestine is impossible. And just as the East African plan is one which does not call for the sole energies of Zionists, so it is one which should appeal to all those Jews who profess the wish to do something tangible for alleviating the condition of their people. There ought, therefore, to be no difficulty, comparable at least, with the advantages to accrue, in forming a special body, ad hoc, to deal with the offer of the British Government, assuming the report justifies our going on with it. A company should be formed to take over the administration and development of the territory—the profits to shareholders being limited, say, to five per cent., and all additional gains being applied to the betterment of the territory. Such a company, I have little doubt, would be able to receive from the British Government terms at once favorable and equitable. The company would undertake pioneer work, and gradually there would be a migration of Jews to the territory, which could thus easily become a large Jewish settlement. Its inhabitants would
בית הספרים הלאומי והאוניברסיטאי ירושלים
