The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 3 · March 1905
96printed page
scan 14 of 52
96
THE MACCABAEAN

But, all these considerations are intensified in face of the fact that to-day we have not one single inch of Palestine —that to-day the Jew, as Jew, has not, in all the wide world, a square inch of land—a foothold—that can be called Jewish. Why, then, needing it so greatly, should Jews refuse the opportunity of securing what will be, at least, an identifiable spot in a tolerably large map of the world? I have heard it objected that no other place but Palestine can appeal to Jews, because it is a Holy Land. But to-day Palestine is not a Holy Land. It never became so for us until it was the Land of the Jews, and it never will be so until once again it becomes our land, the center whence will radiate to the four corners of the earth the best of Jewish ideals, the best of Jewish culture. I have yet to learn that these are so fixed, so inelastic, so incapable of progressive development that a rigid reversion to conditions two thousand years past is inevitable, if we are to place ourselves again within their sphere of influence. If Jewish ideals and Jewish culture are—which I do not believe—inimical to the present day necessities of our people; if—as again, I do not believe—they are compatible with only a superstitious veneration of Palestine as the tomb of our dead past, then those ideals and that culture are self-condemned as retrograde and useless. But I hold otherwise. I hold that our best ideals, our best culture, serve the living life, the present and the future—that those most surely place themselves under their influence who look to Palestine to fulfil the needs of to-day, and not merely to perpetuate the memories of ages that are gone by—that those best appreciate the past who will utilize it for the future—who will employ the land to save the people, rather than the people to save the land. If I did not believe that Palestine

regained, by reason of the historical identification of our people with it, by reason of its being the place on earth to which our people have for ages turned with hope in their bitter suffering, forms the surest prospect of saving Jews to the world as Jews, its mere past would not justify for me the place it holds in our aspirations and our ambitions. And, it is because I see in the East Africa scheme a plan for rescuing a large number of our people from conditions that are likely to cause them to be lost as Jews, and for placing them under conditions that are likely to cause them to be saved as Jews, that I attach to it the importance that I do.

It is often asserted that there is no ground for this anxiety on behalf of our people—that it were better to do nothing until we can reform our nation in Palestine. It is pointed out that two thousand years have rolled away—that we have endured persecution and enjoyed tolerance, that, in turn, we have been stowed away in filthy ghetti, as if we were human offal and been set in the high places of the earth as nobles, and that we have survived. And, it is argued, we can go on yet longer—the more fortunate among us aiding the less fortunate—until we become again effectually a nation in Palestine. But, this line of argument excludes many important differences of condition that have surrounded us these last fifty, sixty, or seventy years, and that were absent until then since the Diaspora. The synagogue bond—partly religious and largely national—has been weakened everywhere. There has been more than one cause for this. The “emancipation” of Jews in Western lands and the influence of freer thought in the world caused the synagogue to water down its Jewish nationalism where Jews, by “emancipation,” were becoming citizens in a fuller and fuller sense