The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 3 · March 1905
95printed page
scan 13 of 52

that only colonization on a large scale, involving political existence as Jews, and which shall be available to all Jews, and not merely a section, can be useful in mitigating the Jewish position. It is objected that Jews who go to make such a settlement will become East Africans, they will not remain Jews. Surely, there must be better chance of their remaining Jews under Jewish autonomy in a Jewish settlement than under the present conditions which prevail in Russia, or with the temptations to assimilate which beset the Jew in Western lands. At least, they will be able to lead better lives, at least they will be free from persecution, and all this must go to the advantage of a movement which seeks to re-establish Jewish nationality.

I advance all this independently of any consideration as to whether the report of the Commission be, or be not, favorable. I hold that it is of the utmost importance to Zionism that some relief—some material relief—should be forthcoming speedily to the Jewish position, every day growing in the intensity of its difficulties and its dangers to our national future. So that if East Africa be not suitable, some other place will have to be sought for our purposes. Even if the Jewish State in Palestine were nearer to-day than we are entitled to consider it, I am clearly of opinion that we should be unwise not first to endeavor to mitigate the Jewish position, if we could, by a large scheme of Jewish settlement on national lines. Our State will be all the stronger if, before its establishment, we shall have assuaged the sordid material misery of Jewry.

Thus, it will be seen that East Africa is, in no sense, a rival to Palestine; it asuredly does not displace it. It cannot—nothing can take the place of Palestine for Jews. There, and there alone, can we again become effectually a nation. But

the conditions under which we find ourselves compel us to undertake another purpose than that for which Palestine alone is reserved. It is, to be sure, distinct in itself, but it will subserve the object to which we have set ourselves as the main plank of our platform. In what sort of sense can it be said that we recede one iota from our determination to secure for the Jewish people a legally recognized home in Palestine when we endeavor to alleviate the condition of the Jewish people on national lines? It may, possibly, be an extension of our original program. But we should be unworthy, indeed, if we pinned ourselves forever to the exact limits of a program. We have said wherein we believe is alone to be found the final solution of the Jewish question, and if we had fifty East Africas we should, I hope, and believe, hold to that still. From that principle we do not swerve a hair's breadth when we say that circumstances now require an immediate relief to Jewish conditions, and we believe that relief will be found in the large Jewish settlement now being proposed to us.

The circumstances, which, to my mind, in the very interests of the future Jewish State, demand some immediate palliative or relief have not special or particular reference to the fact, that, at best, we are yet far from having obtained Palestine as a legally secured home. For, even if we had Palestine as it is to-day, offered to us simultaneously, I am not sure that some place like East Africa—assuming the conditions there are favorable—would not be of immense use to us. The difficulties of placing as large a population as we should desire, or as would desire to be identified with the Jewish State under its auspices, would be lessened considerably if, in addition to Palestine, we had a large settlement practically uninhabited elsewhere.