The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 3 · March 1905
94printed page
scan 12 of 52
Facsimile · scan 12 of 52
Scan of p. 94
Text · transcribed from the scan

surely, be to the advantage of Zionism as a political movement if —presuming such were possible—the status and condition of our people everywhere could forthwith be so altered as to allow them to live their lives in freedom and security. In such case we could be sure that the demand for a national existence proceeded from the highest motives of which man is capable—the desire to secure the continuity of a great historic past in consciousness of the potentiality of a great historic future. Not merely as an exit from galling persecution, not merely as a means of personal comfort and security would the world then understand our demand for a “legally recognized home” in Palestine—not merely would they perceive in Zionist aims a desire to live, but a desire to live again the Jewish life consecrated in Jewish hearts by four thousand years of an allegiance intertwined and sanctified with a never-ceasing communion between the Jew and his God.

Let me advance a local instance. Nothing would be so likely to swell the membership of English Zionist Associations as an outbreak of anti-Semitism in this country. But those who became adherents of our cause in such circumstances would clearly not bring the best spirit to its service. It might well be unconsciously, but none the less surely, the motive inducing them would be, to some extent, unreliable. Thus, Zionists here, in offering opposition to anti-alien legislation, because, in their belief, it must have an anti-Semitic tendency, have not stopped to consider whether a few more members could not be gained for Zionist organizations, by the passing of such legislation. They know that such legislation must wreak hardship on Jews flying from persecution —must mean further degradation for them—and they believe it will

set the running to anti-Semitism: against this the increased support to Zionist Societies weighs nothing.

Hence, it is surely unreasonable to say that the East African project can have no legitimate interest for Zionism because it does not concern Palestine. A big scheme for creating a Jewish settlement of 5,000 square miles in which, gradually, many thousands of Jews could settle, must, in itself, possess keen interest for those who have charged themselves, as Zionists have, with the general upraising of the status of Jews, as inevitably incidental to their regeneration and renationalization. When, however, the proposal is put forth, not for a section of our people under the rule of the Power that made it, but for Jewry as a separate entity in the world, it were madness for Zionists to toss aside, as an unconsidered trifle, this first recognition on the part of a great nation that Zionists were justified in thus regarding Jewry. But the offer of the British Government made further concession to Zionist contention, inasmuch as it was accompanied with a promise of autonomy, which ensure the settlement becoming, and remaining, recognized as definitely a Jewish one. Because the territory to which these proposals are attached is not Palestine, because, hence, the territory can never become a Jewish State, to mention no other considerations; may be—doubtless are— excellent reasons for Zionists refusing to engage, by themselves, as the Zionist organization in the work in East Africa. But they cannot, with reason, either ignore the East Africa proposal, or refuse to take their share in its work. It is not alone that we have here the opportunity of rescuing many thousands of Jews, of raising their status, of largely mitigating the acuteness of the world-position of the Jew, but of justifying the Zionist contention