The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 2 · February 1905
63printed page
scan 29 of 60

Company, which have been distributed by that company, bearing upon their very face irrefragable evidence of the fact that Mr. Dewey is the author. They are earmarked by the method of phonetic spelling of which he is the distinguished promoter. In these circulars, of which we submit a specimen, received directly from the Lake Placid Company, is to be found an elaborate statement of the advantages which the so-called club affords, from which we extract the following:

"No one will be received as a member or guest against whom there is physical, moral, social or race objection or who would be unwelcome to even a small minority. This excludes all consumptives or other invalids, whose presence might injure health or modify others' freedom or enjoyment. This invariable rule is rigidly enforced. It is found impracticable to make exceptions for Jews or others excluded, even when of unusual personal qualifications."

There reside in this State about 750,000 Jews. A large proportion of them are taxpayers, who contribute their quota to the support and maintenance of the institutions of the State, the payment of salaries of public officials, including that which is paid to Mr. Melvil Dewey as the State Librarian. They take a pride in the State and its government. They devote their energies and their intellect to the development of its resources and the fostering of its industries. They strive to raise the standard of public intelligence; to cherish learning; to promote arts, sciences and literature. They have sought to advance the cause of education, to as great an extent, at least, as any part of the citizenship of this Commonwealth. They feel, therefore, that they have a right to demand that one who, as a public servant represents all the people of the State, of whom they are a part, so long as he remains such servant, and receives compensation from the State treasury, under the sanction of your honorable body, shall not with impunity pander to the lowest prejudices of which man is capable.

Thus far the intolerant spirit manifested in Mr. Dewey's circular, which is the far-off echo of the ignorant brutality of mediaeval

times, has gained no foothold in this State. There have been sporadic instances where drunken rowdies have given evidence of similar sentiments by pulling the beards of aged and defenceless men. There have likewise been cases where short-sighted innkeepers have refused accommodations to Jews who have applied for them. It is likewise understood that a number of social clubs have exercised their undoubted privilege of excluding from membership those of the Jewish faith. Far be it from us to take umbrage at such phenomena. With them we have no concern. But when a high public official, who has ben placed by you at the head of an important branch of the educational system of the State, one of whom the youth are accustomed to look for instruction and guidance, for precept and example, either from motives of religious or racial hostility or from considerations of pecuniary greed, or from ignorance and bigotry, can so far forget himself and the duties which he owes to the entire public as to spread broadcast through the land a publication which tends to make of the Jew an outcast and pariah, the State, and you as its right arm, cannot afford to trifle with the offender or allow an infamous precedent to be established. There is but one course to pursue, and that is, to remove from the service of the State the official whose act undermines the very foundations of our government system.

If Mr. Dewey may today impose obloquy upon the Jew, he may to-morrow attack the Catholic, and the next day the Methodist, and thus in turn violate the most sacred sentiments of all the people of the State.

So far as we are concerned, Mr. Dewey may, as the president, and as a stockholder, of the Lake Placid Company, adopt whatever policy he desires; but he must not at the same time remain the State Librarian, or permit his subordinates in his private enterprise to give character to it, as they have done, by adverting to the fact "that Mr. Melvil Dewey, the president of our company, is Librarian of the State of New York."

We are prepared to make satisfactory proof as to all of the statements of fact herein contained."