The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 2 · February 1905
62printed page
scan 28 of 60
Facsimile · scan 28 of 60
Scan of p. 62
Text · transcribed from the scan

There Is No Anti-Semitism in America

FOR many years Zionists have been too timid to allude, even for a moment, to the possibilities of prejudice against the Jews springing up in this country. It is recalled that a Zionist did, not so many years ago, point in alarm to the disbarment of Jews from social clubs, university chapters, and, what was not so awful, from hotels. But when this Zionist had spoken out, a storm of protests arose from conservatives and assimilators. The Zionist movement was reproached with being meddlesome, impertinent and a source of danger to the Jewish people. Whatever the temper of our fellow-citizens of this country towards the Jews, we are not concerned with just now, but we feel it our duty to place on record two facts of recent occurrence, in which the position of the Jews in America is involved. Our readers may draw their own conclusions from them. The first incident arose in the form of a petition presented to the Board of Regents, of the University of the State of New York. The Board of Regents is the directing committee of all state educational institutions, and has supervision over public schools, and, in many cases, over high schools.

THE CASE OF MR. DEWEY.

To the Regents of the University of the State of New York:

Your petitioners respectfully ask for the removal from office of Melvil Dewey, the present State Librarian, whose tenure of office is dependent upon your action.

We are not unmindful of the serious nature of our application, and will therefore proceed to state the facts on which we base the conclusion that he has disqualified him-

self from continuing as the incumbent of the important position he occupies.

Mr. Dewey is the president of the Lake Placid Company, a corporation organized under the laws of this State on June 22, 1891. The original corporate name of the company was Lake Placid Hotel Company. Its articles of incorporation state the objects for which the company was formed to be "the keeping of hotels in the counties of Essex and Franklin in said State, and the purchase of real estate available for hotel purposes and for use in the hotel business, and for the prosecution and improvement of such business and the purchase and erection of hotels at such places as shall seem best in the prosecution of such business, and operating and using necessary conveyances to and from the same."

For some years Mr. Dewey has been the leading and guiding spirit of the Lake Placid Company, the letterheads of the company bear his name and he is recognized by the business community as the most active factor in its operations.

The operations of that company are of wide extent, covering a multitude of activities, which are arranged into departments. Among these departments is what is termed the "Lake Placid Club." It is this club which constitutes the hotel for the conduct of which the corporation was organized, otherwise the Lake Placid Company is carrying on business in absolute violation of the terms of its incorporation and the statutes of this State.

The Lake Placid Company runs the club, furnishes the capital necessary for its operation, makes all purchases, pays all wages, takes all profits and bears all the losses of the club. The club has no assets, is possessed of no legal entity and is what Mr. Dewey describes it to be, a mere department of the Lake Placid Company.

This alleged club has for some time past publicly issued circulars and other printed matter emanating from the Lake Placid