The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 2 · February 1905
50printed page
scan 16 of 60

form I would say it is quite obvious why so much stress is laid upon Messianism. By lopping off much that was burdensome hardly more was left of Judaism than the shell. It became therefore necessary to repair the breach by strengthening it in another direction and what could be easier than emphasizing a doctrine which is purely academic, which has no practical duties attached to it, and which imposes no self-sacrifice or self-denial. How far we have traveled on the path of disowning the Torah I need not here recount. But let me draw your attention to some utterances recently made by two of the most distinguished representatives of America. Dr. Kohler, in a sermon lately preached in New York, made the following statement: "The Alpha and Omega of Judaism is not the Law, but the eternal ethical idea." How such a statement can be reconciled with the undisputed facts of history I do not know. The ethical idea is certainly inherent in the Law, but no ethical idea could live except it be enshrined and expressed in some tangible form. A disembodied spirit does not exist in nature, whatever else it may be in another sphere. It may be possible metaphysically to defend the statement, but it seems to me like pronouncing a divorce between moral thought and moral action, whereas the two are interlinked and indissoluble. On somewhat analogous lines Dr. Emil G. Hirsch, in an article which appears in that excellent annual issued by the Hebrew Union College, argues that not the Law but the prophetic principles constitute the essence of Judaism, for the law operates largely with institutions, while the prophetic vision and ardor is instinct with a new view and outlook. It is this Lehre and not Gesetz, he tells us, "that are originally Jewish." In both these utterances there is a clear sugges-

tion that the Law is not essential to Judaism, the one inscribes on his banner "the eternal ethical idea," and the other subscribes his faith to prophetic principles. This teaching, I may say, en passant, is not quite original. One Paul, who lived nineteen hundred years ago, was its first and ablest exponent.

I hope I have now made clear the complete revolution which has been effected in our ideas as to what constitutes the basic elements of Judaism. Practically the Law and the Prophets have changed.

It is not the prophetic vision, the new view and the outlook extending far away into the airy clouds and woven out of gleams of phantasy—it is not this influence that shapes and molds character, but obedience to the laws of social justice, in discipline and restraint, in acknowledging the supremacy of duty over the promptings of self in the hitherto universally accepted doctrine that the life and health of a Jew depends upon his active performance of commandments, statutes, and judgments. The real mission of the Jew is to keep the Law—to obey it as far as it can be obeyed—each generation as far as it can consistently do so. A religion, however lofty, says Darmstetter, one of the serenest and brightest souls which Judaism has given to the world in the last century, "can influence mankind only by external forms that give it a mold capable of resistance. If prophesy had remained in the realm of Spirit it never would have been able to penetrate Israel and through Israel the world."

Holding, therefore, the view hitherto always maintained in Israel of the respective positions of the Law and the Prophets, and bearing in mind that its conception springs entirely from the latter, I can only draw the conclusion that the Messianic ideal is not an essential doctrine of Judaism, that its proper place belongs to that domain of speculative theology in which many other cognate subjects have their home. It belongs to the poetry of Judaism, but not to its sterner obligations.