The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 2 · February 1905
49printed page
scan 15 of 60
February, 1905)
THE MACCABAEAN
49

cial reverence, and its title and authority were never brought into the arena of discussion. What arguments surged around it were invoked by the various legal interpretations accorded to it by the doctors of the law and the scribes of the time. The Prophets, the Psalms, and the other books stood on a different plane. "They were," says Prof. Robertson Smith, "inspired and authoritative interpretations and applications of the law of Moses, and nothing more." The one was law and doctrine, the other sacred history and religious instruction. From the earliest times a most marked difference was established in their treatment. The Pentateuch was the only book systematically read through in the Synagogue. The reading of excerpts from the Prophets was of later origin. The Mishnah prescribes that he who reads the Pentateuch must not read to the Meturgeman more than one verse and in the Prophet three verses, showing that more care and precaution were taken to convey a correct rendering of the Pentateuch than of the Prophets. To preserve these distinctions a number of ordinances were framed; one was that it was not permitted to sell a scroll of the law and buy with its price the other books of Scripture. In the discussion as to what books came under the law it was not only books like Ecclesiastes and the Song of Songs, whose title to that distinction was questioned, but even the Prophets did not escape. There was thus not only a broad line of demarcation between the Law and the Prophets, but a distinction in essence and principle. "In matters of doctrine," says the same authority that I have already quoted, "the appeal to the Prophets or Hagiographa was not sharply distinguished from appeal to the oral law. Both alike were parts of the Kabbalah, the traditional and

authoritative interpretation of the Pentateuch which stood as the supreme standard above both." In the strictest sense of the word, the Torah is not merely the Book of the Covenant brought over by Ezra from Babylon, but the canonical book received by the Jews and ever since so regarded.

I have dwelt with some particularity of detail on this point, for it is of great and material importance. It affects my subject in both the questions I set myself out to elucidate. It establishes the fact that the Prophets are inferior in canonical authority to the Law, and that the latter formed the basis of all the religious life and institutions of the Jews. It was their charter and constitution; in a word, the Law and Judaism were inseparable, if not, indeed, interchangeable terms. This theory of Judaism has always been accepted and acted upon down to our own time. Now, however, a complete reversal of this principle has been promulgated with the result that Judaism presents a pitiable picture of chaotic and confused conditions. The prominence assigned to Messianism or universalistic Judaism, as some like to call it, is, I contend, one of the graver symptoms of that condition. Its modern history coincides in point of time with that of the Reform movement in the last century. At one of the first Rabbinical conferences held in Germany—that of Frankfurt - on -the - Main — in 1845, the Messianic idea received substantial recognition and it was there decided that it should receive distinct expression in the ritual. The Messianic aim is likewise dealt with in the first article of the statement of principles adopted at the Philadelphia conference in 1869, and since then and always it has been strongly and constantly reiterated and emphasized. If I were dealing with the philosophy of Re-