I fail to reconcile this diversity of creed in so important a matter as the unity of the godhead with the general aspect of a Messianic age, but it does indicate the dawn of a spirit of broad and universal tolerance which is a far more reasonable interpretation than that on which a universal religion is based. If but the essentials of belief could be formulated and universally adopted its outward forms may be as divergent as you like, and they would as now continue to be adjusted in conformity with the differences prevailing in the psychological elements of national character. That is about all that we can hope for in this direction.
It is more than ordinarily noteworthy that the Rabbis never took much stock in the Messianic ideal. Maimonides never embodied it in his creed, nor did Simon Duran or Albo. They nearly always treated it in an enigmatical spirit. Hillel, the son of Gamaliel the third, and not Hillel, the Babylonian, as erroneously stated in the eighth volume of the Jewish Encyclopedia, boldly declared that the Messiah predicted by the prophets had already come in the person of Hezekiah and that no other was to be expected. According to all Rabbinical teaching, says Duschak in his essay, "Die Messiaslchre," the Messianic age lies far away in an unknown future and no mortal may lift the veil that hangs over it. God made the Jews take oath that this great secret sealed seven times would never be revealed, and a certain R. Chasda declared that in the Messianic Kingdom the moon would equal in brilliancy the light of the sun.
Read between the lines and understood in the sense in which the Rabbis were wont to express their thoughts, these opinions clearly indicate a strong skepticism on their part of any coming of a Messiah or a Messianic age. Regarded
from the old optimistic standpoint of the Jewish faith, this attitude is easily comprehensible. The idealism of the Jew ran along lines of sober utility. So long as he bowed to God's will and conformed to His law what care need he have for the future? Did it not all rest with God? In what better hands could it be?
And now I come to my second question. Assuming for the moment that the conception of a Messianic age is a true interpretation of the prophetic ideals it becomes a no less important question to determine the degree of authority attachable to the prophetic utterances and to ascertain in what relation they stand to the rest of the Scriptural writings, especially to the law. It is a great mistake that so many people labor under—a mistake by no means confined to the unlettered classes, that all the books of the Bible are of co-ordinate rank and authority. The Higher Criticism would not be assailed so much by orthodox critics if they were better cognizant of the process of selection which they underwent prior to their collection into one whole. A knowledge of the history of the canon should be made indispensable for every critic of the Bible.
The sacred writings are classified under three sections, the Law, the Prophets, and the Hagiographa. The classification is not arbitrary or artificial, but natural and the degree of sacredness applicable to their component parts differs appreciably. The Law stood on an eminence of its own; it alone was fundamental. In contradistinction to the rest of the books of Scripture which were regarded as Kabbalah—traditional doctrine—the Pentateuch was designated as reading. It was also called the book of the Covenant and the written law, as opposed to the oral law. The Pentateuch was always regarded with spe-
