The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 2 · February 1905
45printed page
scan 11 of 60
February, 1905]
THE MACCABÆAN
45

Truth from Strange Sources THE Southern Rabbinical Conference has been discussing, with some heat, the need for organizing a Synod. "When Doctors disagree who shall decide?" This is the Rabbinical rub. The desire for law and order in Reform comes apparently, and we should say naturally, from the Zionistic Rabbis, the opposition from the antis, though this is probably too harsh a division of the pro- and cons in debate. A Synod would certainly be useful if only to put an end to a condition in which a Jewish Rabbi could honestly say "There is no Jewish creed or belief. Should any lady or layman attending this Conference rise up and ask, What is Judaism? What are its tenets? every one of the thirty-five Rabbis sitting here must blush for shame that he could not answer. There would be from thirty-five Rabbis thirty-five replies." The blush is perhaps of more importance than the answer, but no one will light-heartedly create a situation in which thirty-five Rabbis blushingly stammer out thirty-five individual answers.

There ought to be no blush and just

one clear answer. There should be rule and rhythm in Reform, for in the multitude of opinions there is no certain guidance. It sounds very fine, Spinoza-like, to declare "As long as my God is with me I yield to the dictation of no man and no set of men as to what I shall believe." In fact it is quite right, only Judaism is a question of what the Jews believe, not what one Rabbi imagines God teaches him to believe. As matter stand some Rabbis believe that Judaism is a negation of Christianity and on the positive side Unitarianism with a plus, even a Christian plus at that.

A synod would at least save us many vagaries and yield us a few positive ideas. We could not, no Jew could promise to approve the synodic views without knowing them—it is the layman's privilege to be free—but his respect for such views and doctrines would be a foregone conclusion. The Rabbis have therefore something to gain by creating a synod and the ordinary Jew would be saved something in the way of the present surfeit of individualistic theology.