The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 1 · January 1905
9scan
of 60

THE MACCABÆAN

Vol. VIII.
January, 1905—Shebat, 5665
No. 1

Notes and Reflections

Theology and Life The Jew is no longer a theological problem. The proof of this assertion could not easily

be discovered in the mass of Jewish journals, of which as weeklies there are some fifty issued each week. On the basis of the contents of these publications the Jew is only interested in a religious disputation, and the Jewess desires as literature information concerning her neighbors,comings and goings. The American Jew and Jewess stand on the whole, excepting two or three journals, far apart from the American Jewish press. We might go a good deal farther, and say that the Jewish press as a whole, all the world over, is but a poor reflector of Jewish life. But this seemingly long parenthesis is necessary in so far as there is still a belief that if we could settle certain religious difficulties we could settle all the difficulties that beset our lives.

Under the stress of this hallucination theologic and religious issues are kept steadily to the fore, and every announcement from a theological institution is publicly presumed to stir the Jews throughout the length and breadth of the land. And covered by the abiding interest in what is said by theological, the chiefs, all the Rabbis, of greater or lesser

degree, keep up, individually, or by conferences, and the like, the fiction of a necessary pre-eminence for theological issues.

There is a certain spice of danger in the statement, because it can easily be mishandled, but we assert it as our conviction all the theologic polemics now proceeding, have, the personal issue aside, not the slightest interest for the mass of the Jewish people in the United States. Both orthodox and reform Jews have been done to death by these interminable disputes on insoluble problems. Only here and there do a few feel keenly on the old issues; the majority have been taught that each man is, religiously, a law unto himself, and he proceeds to make that law without reference to what is said by college principals or their pupils. The Jew, a very correct thinker would say, never was a theological problem; that is probably true, but modernity evolved a theology for the Jew, and he has outworn it. It may not be good form to make the admission now, whilst the generation of theologians is still among us, and when it still seeks to guide us, but the truth will out sooner or later, and the sooner the truth of our observation is realized the better we trust it will be for the future Judaism.