A Partial Answer to Lucien Wolf
BY DR. LOUIS N. DEMBITZ
Living away off in a dark corner of the Diaspora, I cannot enter deeply into the facts underlying the Zionist problem; but I can meet the hostile writer at least at some of his points of attack. Mr. Wolf wants the difficulties of the Jews to be remedied right where they now live, and he sees in his own mind a gradual improvement. But it seems to me that as long as the Jews are scattered as a class of traders, artisans and professional men among the nations of the earth, their position may indeed become safer against murder and rapine, such as overtook them at Kischineff and Homel: they may even obtain in Russia and Roumania those equal rights before the law which they already enjoy in the rest of the Christian world, but they never will be fully respected as men and women until they show their ability to form an independent community and to carry on unaided the struggle with the forces of nature. In short, a considerable number of Jews must go back to first principles and get their bread from the soil; their milk from cows grazing on their own meadows; their wool from the fleeces of their own sheep. They must also show that they have enough feeling of order and obedience to law to get along without the outside compression of Gentile rulers. If the experiment is made and fails, I shall recant my Zionism and shall admit that Israel is unfit for even half-independent nationality. Let the experiment be made, if possible in Palestine; if it can not be made there, then in South East Africa.
Mr. Wolf reminds us, that the pre-
tenses of Shabbatai Zebi to the Messiahship and his promise to bring Israel back to its own land, dealt ruin to all the Jews of the Turkish Empire, who until his rise and sudden fall had been rich, learned and respected, and who thereafter became poor, ignorant and despised. He quite overlooks the difference between the charlatan of Smyrna and men like Herzl and Nordau, and the difference also between their methods. In 1666 it was all mystic numbers, signs and wonders; in 1896 to 1904 it has all been sober business. Dr. Herzl and his coadjutors went to work exactly like Zerubbabel and after him Nehemiah. Not a miracle or pretence of a miracle is reported of either of these two men in the biblical books which deal with the return from Babylon and the establishment of the second Commonwealth. Yet this Commonwealth lasted nearly six hundred years; and with the exception of a few years of David and Solomon, the second Commonwealth exceeded the first in cohesion, in the number of its citizens and certainly in their morals and piety. But Zerubbabel and Nehemiah after him were only skillful politicians, working, the former upon King Darius, the latter upon Artexerxes I, just as Dr. Herzl worked upon the Sultan and other European rulers. What succeeded 2400 years ago may succeed again. There were men in Babylonia then, as may be read between the lines in the Deutero-Isaiah, who thought their homes on the Euphrates good enough and threw cold water on the whole movement, just as there are Anti-Zionists
