tolerant or even the congenial comradeship we now enjoy. Where Jews conform to the laws of the land in which they live, identify themselves with their country's interests, obey its laws and live sober and industrious lives, they need not fear expulsion or even social ostracism. To make such individuals unwelcome on the part of any state would be the policy of folly. Whether living the social, economic and political life of our surroundings, we can still live the religious life of the Jew, is another question.
Certainly in a land of their own making the conditions would be revolutionized. Jewish observance would be the prevailing observance. Jewish law would become the law of the land. The Mosaic high-days would become the holidays of the state, and one would needs have to be Jewish in order to be fashionable. Then the environment would be rabbinic and to be faithful to the customs of our fathers would be to move on the line of least resistance. In such a Jewish state the Gentile would be in the minority and the burden of explaining his divergence would devolve on him.
IV.
Is there, then, no alternative between withdrawal from the different lands of our present residence and establishing a new national home in Zion, East Africa or elsewhere—or on the other hand assimilating with our Christian neighbors until we gradually drift out of all recognition of the Jewish religion? Yes, there is a third course. We can live a scattered minority in Christian states and yet be faithful Jews. But we must understand that such is a resolve that calls for heroism; that daily to move against the current of our surroundings demands a vigilance of which average, common-
place persons are hardly capable. To be a loyal Jew in Britain or America (not a half-hearted Jew), to be a Jew with Jewish convictions and to have the courage of his convictions—that demands a life of self-denial. It means that we must renounce much to which we are sorely tempted. It means that we must keep the Sabbath, though the keeping of it may mean the renunciation of some pleasures in the world of leisure, and the renunciation of some money in the world of commerce. It means that we must suffuse our homes with a Jewish atmosphere, even though each time we open our doors the outside air would tend to weaken and dissipate it. It means that at times, though not always, we must take paths different from those of our most cherished friends and live, not aloof, but at least distinct in many of the interests that most deeply touch human emotion. For those gifted with such resolute loyalty to the heritage of Moses and the Prophets in occidental Israel to-day, the Zionist alternative is unnecessary. For those who have the Maccabean faith to resist the Hellenism of our day, surely the victory that awarded their distant fathers will award them. To such we all say God-speed. Such are the idealists who give inspiration to us all. Such souls are the salt of the earth, and without them would life be worth the living?
If we have faith enough to live this harder life, if we have faith enough to infuse it into our children so that they will live it, too, then all is well, and we may tear up the Zionist program. The next generation will have to prove whether we have the courage and the grit to keep the lamp of religion steadily burning, to resist the overwhelming multitudes about us, and to be witnesses of God in the lands of the Gentile.