The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 1 · January 1905
15printed page
scan 23 of 60
Facsimile · scan 23 of 60
Scan of p. 15
Text · transcribed from the scan

economic; the other religious. Most emphasis and attention seem to be devoted to the former; the latter is considered only by the way. Yet it is only Zionism on the second ground that I would for a moment espouse.

II.

Let us consider Zionism as a political expediency first. "Let us live in our own country," say these Zionists. "We cannot live safely and happily in the lands of the Gentiles. Anti-Semitism has come to stay and will deepen with the years. We have tried to assimilate with our surroundings and we have failed. The great bulk of us have not even tried."

This side of Zionism has been recently answered by Mr. Lucien Wolf in the columns of the "Jewish Quarterly Review." He has pointed out in arguments that I consider convincing that anti-Semitism is a passing wave and already on the wane, that the political and social future of the Jew is reassuring, that the sun of emancipation fully risen on the western lands is already sending its dawning rays further toward the east. Even in Russia we begin to see the glimmer of its roseate hue. The Pale of Settlement is beginning to widen for the Jews, who are not emigrating from it to other lands, while the regime of Sviatopolk-Mirsky and the assembling of the Zemstvos is ushering in an era of freedom and of individual rights for all Russians, Jewish and Gentile.

Mr. Wolf proves with scholarly data that the era of assimilation begun by Mendelssohn with his colleagues and disciples, Dohm, Lessing, and Lavater—and Wessely, Homberg and Friedlander—has achieved great things in its short life

of a century. To declare it pessimistically a failure is to ignore some of the best achievements of the Jew. Ever since the Mendelssohn era our brethren have been steadily passing from the gates of their ghettos and Judengassen to mingle with the world about them, not merely onlookers and denizens, but as participators and citizens. enthusiastically identifying themselves with the world's culture and the world's causes; winning laurels in every great field of endeavor and working side by side and hand in hand with their fellowman for all human ideals.

I could not, therefore, agree with Herzl, Nordau or Zangwill, that we cannot assimilate with our surroundings without intermarriage. We can; we have. The Jews in Europe, after a millenial residence there, have become Europeans; they can no longer be called Asiatics. They are not an alien race, they are not a separate race at all. They belong to the people among whom they live, not differentiated from them more widely than some among them differentiate from each other. The charge that we do not enter into the aims and struggles of those about us who differ only in religion is a mistaken charge, whether made by our friends or by our enemies. Just as soon as the Jew emerges from the ghetto and is made but tolerably comfortable under the law of the new fatherland, he becomes more loyal than the king. As Englishmen they die on the South African velt, fighting against the Boers, and even as Russians on the plains of Plevna, fighting against the enemies of a step-fatherland. No, there is no fear, even without intermarriage, that the Jews will not assimilate fast enough with the Gentile people about them. There is rather the fear that they will assimilate all too fast, with intermarriage as a natural