Religion and Zionism
We recently commemorated the triumph of the Maccabean Jews over the Greek Syrians. A glorious victory, not military, but moral; for the tyrannic king, Antiochus, who held sway over Judea, would have extirpated the Israelitish faith and the Israelitish people in the desire to reduce all his subject races to pagan uniformity. So the issue was Jupiter or Jehovah, the cult of Baal and Bacchus or the Mosaic Law and the mission of Israel.
That was not the whole story—the struggle against the heathen world without. There was a preliminary struggle against heathen Jews within. Before Antiochus appeared upon the scene and had turned the Jerusalem temple into a shrine of Zeus, the temptation to live the life of their Greek surroundings proved too alluring for the more worldly of our ancestors. So they began by adopting Greek manners and ended with accepting Greek morals. Had they accepted only the intellectual Greek culture, that would have been broadening and exalting. But it was hard to draw the line, and some yielded to the Greek religious cult, and that could only be debasing.
But the loyal and true gathered around the banner of Judas, whom they styled Maccabee, and threw down the gauntlet to their over-lord. They fought with spiritual weapons from the armory of faith, as well as with swords and spears, against the legions of Lysias, Gorgias and Nicanor—and they conquered. Ideals proved stronger than battalions, and the religious victory was followed by a political success. They threw off the yoke of Greek-Syrian rule, and under
the Hasmonean family became an independent nation again. This reacted advantageously on the Faith; for in a realm wholly Judean they could the better create an environment wholly Jewish. Mark the inference, for it bears upon the issues of to-day.
I.
Mr. Israel Zangwill recently said:
“For nineteen hundred years the Jews have been trying to do an impossible thing, living among an alien people, not to do in Rome as the Romans do. * * * * * We have chosen to be clannish and stand-offish * * * Hence we have spurned intermarriage, the only natural process by which two alien races can be welded into one.”
This declaration has been bitterly resented and has even been called anti-Semitic. We shall presently see to what extent it was justified. But what is Mr. Zangwill’s remedy for the evil that he in a Jewish land where to do as the posits? Zionism. Let the Jews live Romans do, will be to live as the Jews live, where their environment will be of their own people and their own making; where the minority that will have to justify its being will be the Gentile. Let the Jew have a land of his own as did Maccabean Israel two thousand years ago, where the institutions will be adapted to their religious needs and the law of the land conform to their inherited beliefs and customs. Let them have their own home rule. To live the Jewish life will be to flow with the tide and not against it.
There are two prime arguments given for Zionism—the one, political, social,