The Maccabaean · Vol. VIII, No. 1 · January 1905
2printed page
scan 10 of 60

Healing the Breach

The time is approaching for the healing of the breach which the theological fight began; and which mutual disrespect widened. The several elements in American Jewish life have sore need of each other, and will need each other more and more in the ears to come. Both millionaire and pauper have dimly begun to perceive this and there are two classes between them and the need is not such as shall place the poor in the sad position of the beggar, and a good deal of it will be done by the rich. There is no good reason why this mutual co-operation should not begin now, instead of in a moment of stress, and we believe that nothing hinders it except the class difference fostered by a theological dispute. This theology makes for a horrid condition which we must term congregationalism. A small Jewish city has two Jewish worlds, a big city has ten to fifty. These little worlds come into constant friction with each other very often because they have Rabbis whose apparent business in life is to maintain a theological dispute which their congregants in actual life ignore. Of course this does not apply to all Rabbis, but it is true that a city with two congregations where only one congregation has a Rabbi the community generally harmonizes better than in a city where the two congregations manage to provide for two Rabbis. And we go a step further, and say that where a young Rabbi manages to forget whether his father was born an hour by train, or by telegraph beyond Berlin by train, or by telegraph beyond Berlin, his Reform theology does not prevent his winning the regard of the most stern orthodox, and we believe it is better for a Rabbi to have the esteem of a Jew, who is an able critic, than to be held to a congregation by the slender thread of Christian approbation.

Communal Differences

It would be the excess of folly to ascribe the communal differences which do prevail as entirely the result of religious opinions, and there wouldbeas little justice in regarding the Rabbisasthemainspringof the various bickerings which form the spice of communal life, but it is a fact that the supposed religious difference is used as an excuse to hide social prejudices of which many are ashamed. The Russian Jew who joins a Reform congregation often takes the most Bavarian view of his own compatriots, in order to be admitted into German Jewish circles, and in this he too often has the tacit support of the younger Rabbis. Orthodox in many cities has come to be understood not as a religious adherence to tradition, but lower caste plus poverty. There is a danger in this for both sections, and the remedy, whatever it is, certainly is not the theological talks of the various Rabbinic conferences. The first thing that a Rabbi should have borne in on him is that a Jew is a Jew wherever he was born or raised, and that he at least should set a wholesome example by proving that he is a brother to every Jew who approaches him, be he old or young, "froom" or "link." Every Rabbi who has done this is deservedly popular, independent of his acquirements, and where he does not do this, where he holds himself to be the spiritual guide of the paying members of his congregation, he achieves the disrespect of a section of the Jews in the city in which he resides. We are perfectly aware that most of the provincial Rabbis could cite instances of their efforts on behalf of immigrants, and so forth, but we are equally well aware that many of them have but the remotest knowledge of the immigrant congregation in their city, or know only of those who are charity cases. On the