The Maccabaean · Vol. VII, No. 6 · December 1904
309printed page
scan 43 of 74
December 1904]
THE MACCABÆAN
309

The Maccabæan

EDITORIAL PAGES J. DE HAAS, Editor
DECEMBER, 1904

EAST AFRICA

Mr. L. J. Greenberg who, as it were, has taken charge of the East African project, has obtained from Sir Harry Johnson a letter showing that the writer is not averse to the Jewish settlement in the particular section of the East African Protectorate, and moreover claiming that the tract of land is of value and of great promise. The latter point the Zionist Commission of Inquiry will discover for itself, but Sir Harry Johnson's attitude removes one difficulty, that of opposition to the Jewish settlement. We could not accept, with due regard to ourselves, what is given without the full consent of representative Englishmen. There could be no question that such a settlement should desire more than the fullest local autonomy —a Jewish state within the British empire, independent of British Imperial control, is unthinkable. Nor do our state needs go beyond control within our own borders, when we possess such. The Jew has no need of national treaty making powers, but of autonomy at home. This England offers; and this, in the most careful phrase, the British proconsul, even as do the authorities in the Foreign Office, approves. For the Roumanian born "alien," and the disowned Russian, this offer of a home means a great deal. It outvies, in fact, some of his most wonderful dreams.

We do not deny the practicability of this scheme, nor its general utility, but we cannot disguise from ourselves either that Zionism is not a narrow utilitarianism. Zionism is a movement for the molding of the Jewish future, not a, or any Jewish future: and as to the future, Sir Harrv John-

If wisely handled, this project may yet gain for us unity in Israel, so that this piece of Herzl's politics may result in a triumph for Herzl's real idea.

CONVENTIONS AND CONGRESSES.

It is a serious admission to make, but we do not fear to state that we Zionists have much yet to learn of organization. When a Convention is about to be held, or a Congress is being spoken of, our fellow-workers are all aglow as to the prospects before them for good solid reforms. Weeks pass, and month follows month, but what is done? The discussions are held in local club-rooms, born out of earnestness of purpose, but killed by lack of circulation. It is true, the Federation should be censured. It is true Vienna could do many things better. But when Mr. Cohen, of Tacoma, wants to criticise these organizations he calls a meeting of his neighbors and proceeds to demolish the wrongs and berate the Federation and the Actions Comite, in good round terms, and after he has finished he goes home and sleeps the sleep of the just.

That's all very well, but it does no body any good. This year we ask our readers to