The Maccabaean · Vol. VII, No. 6 · December 1904
303printed page
scan 37 of 74
December, 1904]
THE MACCABÆAN
803

honors. He knew when a man was red-hot after office, but he never bargained with that man. He admired the students and their ebullitions, and he even forced the Actions Comite to pay the deficit on the Russian Students' Congress in Basle in 1901; he was keenly appreciative of the new art they were producing, but he did not believe they understood anything of politics. As a cultur, it was a supreme joke with him. He said of an address of Dr. Gaster's on Jewish Culture, "It is magnificent poetry, but not even Gaster could say what he means." And to Gaster, who asked him how he stood on the question, he said something worse. "If Jewish culture means permission to smoke on Sabbath, I am all for it."

Here, then, Herzl was not the Jew, certainly not the Jew of the Ghetto, but I think very much the Jew after the Maimonides pattern, very much a Jew after Akiba’s type, very much a Jew like Simon ben Goriah, Eleazer, and those who threw the Eagle off the Temple.

Our blunder, the common blunder, was to ask Herzl to live down to the normal Jewish type. Instead, we should ask the Jews to live up to the Herzl type, for that is the real type of Jew. And if we did, suffering would not be the badge of our tribe, nor would the petty chicaneries of congregationalism and institutionalism fill our lives. There would be a break. The pulpit would cease to be a mouthing place of mortalities and vague spiritualities, and instead every synagogue and temple would be a centre point of national defence. The Jewish people would know of their existence from winning themselves, not by reason of

their sufferings; the rich would not be so densely ignorant of the real things of our existence; the poor would be more self-reliant. We might lose a few habits and customs, the shoulder-shrug of religion; but gain an infinite recompense in national feeling. We would not talk of the dry and the wet nurse culture; but culture would come as the resultant of our active lives, as real culture has come to all peoples—the needs of leisure as they follow the routine of a busy life. We would not make shift to inaugurate petty policies, but stand squared shoulder for great achievement. We might fail, we might sink, but far better a splendid failure, and a final grand overthrow, than a frittering away of effort on a thousand petty ways of staving off the inevitable.

And Herzl was the real Jew—the brother to our ancient heroic spirits; for the real man gives, as the real man in all nations gives, his life, his soul, and his honor for his cause. This Herzl gave, and it is not the future grave in Zion, but death in the unending struggle, the leader stricken in the battle, that proved how real a Jew was Herzl. And we others, our reality as Jews must be proven, not by our capacity for death, but our willingness to sacrifice and carry on under a single flag, with a single-war-cry, the battle of our nation; by our ability to ignore all things until the war is over, and we have re-established our people, and regained our land. Rouse the masses to this, and the real Jew begins to walk the earth, and the shadow of the Ghetto will fade into the gloomy recesses of the past.

. Original from NEW YORK PUBLIC LIBRARY