The Maccabaean · Vol. VII, No. 5 · November 1904
221printed page
scan 9 of 56
Facsimile · scan 9 of 56
Scan of p. 221
Text · transcribed from the scan

FIRST ADDRESS TO THE MASSES

From Herzl's first address to the Jewish masses (delivered at the Jewish Workingmen's Club, London, July 12th, 1896).

Many learned disquisitions and arguments have not been able to solve the Jewish question. It has become more evident that the nations do not desire our emancipation. It is in their own interest, in the interest of their own existence, that they must resist our entry into competition with them on an equal footing. The only solution, then, lies in our own nationality. The fact has been recognized in the latest forms of allaying the effects of persecution. Among these is the notable effort of the late lamented Baron Hirsch in Argentine. Though this indicated a proper tendency, there is much in his methods which stood in the way of success. Baron Hirsch chose for the field of his operations a country which did not act as a magnet for our people. . . .

To send Jews to fresh places is to open the Jewish question and cause persecution in those new countries wherever their prosperity shows itself. Although it was necessary to help those of our colonists—flesh of our flesh—who seek to maintain themselves, and establish our reputation in agriculture, he could not look upon it as a solution of the Jewish question; nor was it right for us to encourage those undertakings, without first acquiring what he sought to obtain. Our efforts must be concentrated on gaining our acknowledgement as a State, for we are a people, though crushed and persecuted, a people playing a very important part among the nations. What we require is a country—a home—where our efforts shall be concentrated on the development of our

own State, and the opportunities for the employment of a great amount of genius that is now wasted among us. We need not a colony, nor a series of colonies, but a real and fundamentally established State. There are those among our own people to whom the idea of a Jewish State is a visionary and impossible idea. But it is not considered so visionary and impossible by politicians in high places; and if we only unite in believing it possible, it can be carried out. The scheme need not take the precise form he had outlined. Let all Jewry take the problem in hand, and work it out in the best possible manner. He could not contrive nor conceive any normally constituted individual, Jew or non-Jew, who in his heart of hearts, apart from his own personal fears of position, or pecuniary loss, is devoid of that national feeling on which a Jewish State could be founded. It is an idle fear that our patriotism will be suspected, and if there is such an error current, facts will bely it. . . .

It has been objected that our State will be constituted of the proletariat class. They know no history who thus object. All States have been established by and with the proletariat, who alone, by the toil of their hands, have created industry and turned waste places into green fields. Look at the advantages of a latter day migration. For we shall carry with us all the advantages of the advance of modern science and civilization. The rapidity with which news is circulated is one of the most remarkable phenomena of our times, and ours will have the advantage of a fully organized and equipped press. We may work away at the realization of our plans without the participation of the mass of our people, for we can wait until our efforts are accompanied with success, and