The Maccabæan
EDITORIAL PAGES J. DE HAAS, Editor
THE CRISIS
Confession is at length made that the Jewish situation has reached a critical condition. The Jews will emigrate from Eastern Europe, they are emigrating to America to the number of fifty thousand per annum, and we need both places of settlement and organized emigration. Emigrate, but where to? The English Jewish community has sent out two officials to United States but as these have not been found, a less imposing description will be given to the tours of the investigators. The Honorable Simon Wolf is touring the West as an advocate of distribution. The German Hilfverein proposes to relieve the pressure of western emigration by turning the Roumanian emigrants to Italy which, having only forty thousand Jews, should have room for more.
The Zionists in Europe, who are doing their full share, are being urged to help organize the emigration in the interest of the emigrants. Tremendous difficulties are experienced in dealing with the Russian Jews who, in order to reach America via France, pass through Basile. The emigrants who seek the same haven by travelling through a Dutch port are, owing to lack of means, refused at the Dutch frontier and returned to Germany; the German authorities reconsign them to Holland; being rejected again, the poor people are often compelled to recross Germany twice before they are finally allowed to cross the Dutch frontier en route for the port of embarkation.
The picture is deplorable. From a Russian village to a new American city is a road of hardship and pain. The emigrant is "human freight"—freight with human feelings. How much of the freight feeling remains with him to mar his future life we cannot pause to consider. Thousands leave their homes penniless to wander whither? Anywhere. Mere freight has a positive destination—it is of value to consignor and consignee.
Beyond question, the creation of an international board of Jewish emigration is necessary. But we fail to see how it is to be effected. Any systematizati of emigration means an increase of emigration, it means an understanding with the governments through whose countries the Jews must pass to their final destinati . It means money to help the emigrants; it means a final destination. We are not surprised that the dumping grounds are being sought; nor are we surprised at the objection to the project out of a fear of an increase in the volume of. emigration. It is being discovered that what affects the mass of Jewry, it affects the minority. Official Jewry is roused from slur her, it declares; something must be done.
The Russian Jews, as some have quaintly put it, are "fleeing from the Japanese;" they are fleeing from starvation; they are trying to race away from persecution. Will they, can they succeed? Organization of emigration will save suffering that is so much gained but unless it can say where to the Jews shall emigrate, it offers them no reasonable security for the future.
We fear that many Zionists, in their pity for the suffering emigrants, do not see that one cannot put purpose into the emigrant, and that it is almost impossible to construct a chain of official organizations which shall transfer the Jew to some dumping ground. The evils from which the emigrant suffers are inherent in the situation. After a variety of vicissitudes, the Jew arrives in New York, which is beset by its own internal problem of congested population. An attempt is made to help the emigrant. He is sent South and West in accordance with economic possibilities. Fifty Jews are placeable here, five there. This opportunity cannot be foreseen, and it cannot be created. Something more than the opportunity presented by labor requirements in a regular centre is required to deplete New York, and to meet the needs of the immigrants. The seekers after new dumping grounds recognize this. They have found out that the overflow of the tide of migration cannot be discharged into a few inch pipes. And so, perhaps from a recognition of the needs of the emigrants,
