The Maccabaean · Vol. VII, No. 5 · November 1904
243printed page
scan 31 of 56
November, 1904]
THE MACCABÆAN
243

for his mordant wit. Ten years ago, Zangwill bore a remote facial resemblance to Disraeli—he had the kiss curl pendant on his forehead and cultivated it—and as the English Jews had a longing for a Jewish Disraeli, there was many a hope that Zangwill, once outside the Ghetto, might achieve a Beacons- fieldian career. But the possible Disraeli lacked the race passion of the real Disraeli. The latter had given the Jews the benefit of his romantic imagination ; the former knew them and saw them as a Journalist sees men and things. He had been taught not to feel, only to describe —he did not feel. When his “Dreamers of the Ghetto” was published, the writer ventured upon an analysis of the collection of stories; and, under the heading “Zangwill’s Zionism,” and again in an article “Israel and Zangwill,” ventured the deduction that the portrayer of Jewish life must eventually enter the camp of those who felt the Jewish life. _

Though attracted privately, Zangwill made no public response to these suggestions. Even later, writing for an American public, he maintained the philosophic attitude—which is not wholly philosophic—of seeing two sides of the issue. But in America, impressed by the abnormality of American Jewish life, he ventured his first step forward. He challenged Jewish opinion by urging that either Rome or Jerusalem should be the goal of Jewish existence. His was an open mind, desirous of attaining a logical solution of the Jewish problem. He ignored the fact that Hess had looked upon Rome as an example for the new Jerusalem; in short, he did not feel the Jewish life.

This latter phrase, repeated, calls, perhaps, for an explanation. To the writer's mind, it is the feeling of Jewish life that makes Zionism. George Eliot's

wonderful phrase, “he who feels the life of his people stirring within his own veins, must explain it. He who feels that “stirring” is the Zionist; he feels not the suffering but the existence of his race, and to him there must ever be the Zionistic thought, and if not the sense of responsibility, at least the desire to act for his race. And the “stirring” is not to be cultivated Dy any pedagogic method, such as our culturists seek to use. It is of the red corpuscles in the blood, quickened and increased by life in the. open, a mother’s whisper of Jewish pride flourishing in a. loyal manhöod or womanhood. — _

Zangwill did not feel this whilst per- pending his varying solutions; but gradually his philosophy became colored with the blue and white of Zion. After all, no one was making a bold step to lead the Jews to Rome, but some Jews were setting out on the long journey to Palestine. In Palestine he had seen a child, with six fingers on one hand, begging— an impression of its abnormality; but the thought grew apace—an abnormal people belonged to an abnormal land; artistically, the picture would be complete— the fantastic Jew surrounded by the bizarre of Palestine. The Western Wall has humbled the Coliseum by reason of the proximity of the human fable to the mural legend. But he was not moved by it. The eloquence of his characters did not soar. The thought that he had given to the creatures of his brain was "if the nations cast us out, we could draw together and form a nation as of yore."— an earlier version of Herzl's dictum, a nation is made by its enemies. Zionists in congress were simply "Dreamers of the Ghetto." Still, some measure of the dream flitted before his vision. —

So grew Zangwill's Zionism. He still saw the paradox and hammered the head