main object. The fear of the Russian Zionists was well founded. To gain the assimilating anti-Zionists we must compromise with them, and they will be gained only as we let go the national idea. Our rich philanthropists will not be lured into the Zionist camp by any subterfuge. We assert Jewish nationality; they deny and oppose it. Do you think that East Africa or Palestine or New Mexico will make them lose their dread of Jewish nationality? They will oppose everything that tends to perpetuate our separate racial existence, and until they are convinced that this opposition to separate nationality is wrong, they will not help us to gain our national ends by any detour.
And they will act injuriously upon our movement, for should they join us in any enterprise, they will be the diluting element; they will weaken the ardor of our enthusiasts, for by the display of the power of money—for with that we can do much—our best workers will be discouraged in their work among the masses. Our manhood suffrage, our democracy will be superseded by an oligarchy of wealth. The Jewish people must save themselves. It is strange that Mr. Zangwill, who himself noticed the wrongs perpetrated by philanthropic men of wealth, should incline to place more value on money than on manhood, on the power of a few people, rather than on the strength and enthusiasm of a people.
And that is a real danger too, not an unfounded fear. We must preserve the emphasis on the people, not on people. The Princes in Israel have been our great stumbling blocks by reason of their goodness, their generosity, their care of less fortunate brethren, for they have weakened the character of our people, made it difficult for them ever to think of
helping themselves. That was the charge made by Zangwill against our philanthropists. Our movement has been free from such influences, for the workers in Zion, in the uniformed ranks, have been men and women who stand on practically the same economic footing as the proletariat.
Our movement is not a Palestine affair; it is more than that. We must secure a safeguarded home for the Jewish people, but we must create the spirit of rationalism among the people. We are building from the people upward. Without the Jewish people we can make not one step forward. They are our greatest obstacles. No scattered force will ever reach Zion or East Africa. They are the thermometer of the success of our movement. We have little else to fear. The need to do something should not frighten us. If the people will not move, no red flag of danger will frighten them to action. We are dealing with the revival of a race; we need give heed to the notion that we "must go before the country" with something done or something proposed to be done.
Therefore the value of East Africa for colonization has nothing to do with the merits of a detour. Nor does the merit of any other territory. Nor does the fact that such a colony will permit experiments. The question is, Are the Zionists behind it, body and soul? Have we a sturdy army of determined men and women who are willing to make a detour?
Logic has nothing to do with the case. We are dealing with human beings, with sentiment and enthusiasm; and unless we find that enthusiasm and sentiment behind the new issue, unless we feel that at least those who have gone with us thus far are willing to make this diversion, we should abandon it until such an en-