The Maccabaean · Vol. VII, No. 5 · November 1904
228printed page
scan 16 of 56

ment has been one on the part of the majority, or a minority to safeguard its existence by keeping the balance of a people true and loyal to the ideals and aims of that nation. This is the character of the Jewish movement.

Always a small people amongst the great nations, never a world power, the movement of the Jews has been confined to the maintenance and expression of self. (The accomplishment of that purpose, methods and the like are not discussable in this paper.) Such an attitude is, of course, only ideal when the task of preserving an individuality is undertaken in the face of great odds. Such has been the lot of the Jew, and the abnormal character of the pressure put upon him has compelled him, as it were, to turn within himself, and regard even the petty tricks of habit as sacred because they go to make up his individuality. Had we not been playing tricks with our own mentality—did not a whole section of our people indulge in a most inglorious game of self-deception—the suggestion, “Jew, be true to thyself” would be a worn-out, threadbare platitude, if not an insult to our understanding and our self-loyalty.

But in all the smaller nations there have been times when a small and intense element have had to band themselves together in order to sound effectually a note of warning against the danger of absorption. The Dutch, with their Teutonic base, have been so fearful of slipping into Germanism that they have at times careened violently to the French; the little Balkan nations, with their Slavonic roots, fear being enfolded in the grizzly Russian coat. The Jews, having no basis in common with any other nation, have had to fear absorption by all the nations, even as in Palestine times the Jews were hedged in

between the nations. There has always been a Jewish movement. An element in every nation will cry out against absorption, because it is cowardly, degrading and disloyal, though it may be convenient and advantageous to the individual.

We cannot pretend to argue out such an emotion as patriotism, but it exists, and is a universal prompter of conduct, so that it goes first and foremost as a principle of conduct of the affairs of the world. By general acclaim, it is almost the highest virtue, certainly the highest in public life. It is this drumbeat to life that the Jewish movement is making to the Jewish people, and this drum-beat has been sounding throughout the ages. If we could only gather our history in one hand; if we could realize the drift of all the currents that make eighteen centuries of our record, we would find its philosophy self-preservative; we would hear amid pain and anguish, amid prayer and entreaty, between fear and hope, real thought to which the Jewish mind converged—the idea that we now call the Jewish movement—the pride and patriotism of the Jew.

The Jewish movement, that is, Zionism, is nothing but a normal standard of patriotism; as such it is the movement of the Jews, all other movements amongst the Jews must be smaller and of less importance. And, examined with a cool eye, one finds in the Zionist movement just those phenomena, accentuated in our case, which one finds amongst other patriotic movements called forth by stress, the mixing of elements, the forgetting of class and creed, and the appeal to equality. What, nowever, is weak in the Jews as a whole is that the onlooking Jew is often callous, indifferent towards or ignorant of the