The Maccabaean · Vol. VII, No. 2 · August 1904
110printed page
scan 48 of 48
110
THE MACCABÆAN
August, 1904

The Maccabæan

EDITORIAL PAGES J. DE HAAS, EDITOR

August, 1904.

The Idea and Herzl

Just as the flowers bud imperceptibly, so do ideas, and it is beyond the power of the human mind to analyze their growth, to discover why this idea has prominence over another, why this thought takes root while another withers and dies away. But while the flower, planted in sterile soil, may die and nothing be left of it to remind us of its being, ideas can never die. Nothing once expressed by the human mind is ever lost, for there is no sterile soil for ideas. Like the grain in the Egyptian sarcophagus, it may lie dormant for centuries, but once admitted to the germinating air, it resumes its arrested growth, as if nothing had happened to stay it.

Ideas have often shot up in a night, and when men have wondered some researchful mind has traced it to an origin somewhere in the past, and told us that such and such a man, centuries ago, expressed this new idea, in this book, on this page and that line.

There have been ideas that have swung about in the shuttle of the human mind, the center of fantastic, superstitious and enthusiastic dreams. They have been enflowered in the verses of wild-brained poets. Philosophers have made them the essence of great systems, arches with ethereal keystones. Preachers have used them as themes for their burning eloquence and thus earned the sobriquet of impractical. But, in spite of all this energy, the ideas have not responded to these attempts to fan them into life.

Then, over night, some little incident has happened, some word has been spoken, some collision of alien accents has occurred, and wonder of wonders, the idea long wandering about, seeing a human habitation, takes root, takes a definite meaning, establishes its principles, its corollaries, its implications, its criticism of life and thus flowers. Obscured by phrases, or figures of speech, or lamentation, indefinite, chaotic, it bursts forth into life in the open, explainable and convincing.

When an idea is born in that way, men are of use in one of two capacities. They are either swept away by its force, become its slaves, its servitors, its unquestioning, fanatical, self-sacrificing tools; or instead of its instruments, they become its pilots, its directors, its explainers.

Such an idea was Zionism, and its pilot was Theodor Herzl.

Since the eventful Ninth of Ab, when the nation, in its incarnated form, was scattered, Zionism has been in the air. It had been expressed by poets, religious teachers, Christians, laymen and nondescript Luftmenschen. It has been a prayer, an elegy, a prophecy; it had no bounds and no one tried to bound it. It had no position and no one defended it. It was an emotion, a longing, a desire, a Utopia, whatever you please. Suddenly, after much puttering, dissension, aimlessness, lamentation, what not, it bursts into being with the publication of Herzl's Jewish State. The Jewish State, an incident, crystalized the Wandering Idea. It gave it form, positiveness, audacity. It was the strong man's interpretation of the Jewish question. It was the strong man's longing for the end of the drama of shame, which the Jewish people have been playing for some twenty centuries.

Was Herzl, our beloved leader, the Star of the Winning Hope, was he the