The Maccabaean · Vol. VII, No. 1 · July 1904
6printed page
scan 8 of 66
Facsimile · scan 8 of 66
Scan of p. 6
Text · transcribed from the scan

will not be so critical as ourselves, who find in the book a failure to seize an opportunity. The author brings us to the foot of the cave in which the great Isaiah is resting, and there leaves us; we hear of, but we do not see the prophet. And yet what a word picture were possible there; perhaps a religious sentiment kept the author from a task on which many critical straws would have been subsequently broken; and, perhaps, therefore, he was right in refraining from the task.

* * *

A curious paradox is involved in the record and meaning of the Jewish month through which we are now passing. Tammuz, as a planetary sign, denotes fruitfulness and growth; and yet history, from the seventeenth day, gives us nothing but a record of sorrow and suggests mourning.

During the period of normal Jewish life in Palestine, Tammuz must have been a period of brightness, but the Jew is so tinged with the melancholy of historic tragedy that he regards Tammuz as existing, as it were, from the date which marks the beginning of the end of the siege of Jerusalem. First, Nebuchadnezzar made a breach in the walls of Jerusalem on that date; and six centuries later, during the last and final siege by Titus, the sacrifices were stopped in the Temple on that day —never to be resumed. It is a very easy, and indeed, a very light task to repeat or write these phrases; for is not all of this written in the books of the Jews, and can it not be found in one form or another in chronological tables? The hard thing to understand is that these facts have remained unforgotten; harder still is it to realize, even when one is a Jew, that there exists

to-day a people to whom these things are living records, and more difficult still is it to appreciate that time has not withered nor sapped this people's power of remembering. In a peculiar esoteric way the planetary sign of Tammuz is appropriate to the Jewish history of the month.

* * *

A Season of Sorrow. The most obvious impulse, on considering the record of Tammuz, is to observe that these things are in the Jewish calendar, and that Judaism has kept alive the idea of mourning on this day. It might with equal truth, perhaps, be said, that as many fail to observe this day as do observe it, and that in general, the rigidity of the "three weeks" has gone by the boards. Even, perhaps, with justice it might be commented that a large number of the readers of these reflections have been educated in ignorance of the abstinence regulations of the period of mourning extending from Tammuz 17 to Ab 9.

And yet, when in sooth all this has been said, the phenomenon remains. Nebuchadnezzar was to the sceptic, more or less of a mythical personage, until his record of the siege of Jerusalem was deciphered on an Assyrian clay tablet, and the whole story identified by means of the Jewish writings. Men have had to dig deep in the sands of Babylon to find traces of the conquering Assyrian, whilst the conquered Israel has become as the sand in numbers.

The seventeenth day of Tammuz is a season of sorrow because it records the anniversary of two signal defeats, but in the wailing of the Kinnoth, there is room for joy that comes from the sense of life itself—that there is someone left alive to remember and mourn the long ago.