THE MACCABAEAN
Notes and Reflections
At the “impressively simple” ceremony of orBad Phrases. daining ten ministers of the Hebrew Union College, Dr. Kaufmann Kohler said, amongst many other things: “The Zionist who clamors for a specific Jewish land does not understand the designs of God and the nature of Judaism.” Now, we have no intention of arguing Zionism, or this particular remark here, for it is with the observaton itself that we wish to deal. Dr. Kohler does not stand alone amongst the undogmatized who lay down dogmas. Thousands of all ministers of all faiths speak in one breath of the “inscrutable ways of Providence,” and, in another, inform those whom they assail that they (the assailed) do not understand the designs of God, inferring thereby that the assailant does. Now, with all due respect to Dr. Kohler, whatever elese he knows, the one thing he does not know, nor any other man knows, is that of the illimitable, whilst man confesses to his limitations. Theology cannot overcome that; it presents us with men’s reasoning, and the greatest metaphysician has not penetrated beyond human powers of knowledge.
In days of old he who proclaimed a knowledge, and therefore an understanding of God's designs, was hailed as a prophet, a seer, as a man inspired; for even the least speculative peoples realized that
if such knowledge existed it came from without, and was a peculiar gift to a particular man. But we do not wish to belabor the point further. The absurdity of the phrase lies on the face of it, and it should be consigned to that oblivion which so many other like phrases well merit, but have not yet attained.
*** Quite a library could be collected of novels rangGroping. ing around the monarchical period of Jewish history. The playwright has even seized upon David and brought the head of Goliath on the stage, a clumsy enough suggestion of realism. The newest addition to this Biblical romantic literature is Mr. Louis Pendleton's "In Assyrian Tents,"* which treats of that period when "The Assyrian came down like a wolf on the fold." The book is intended for youngsters, and it contains sufficient of the elements of desperate adventure to satisfy any ordinary young mind, which has heretofore satiated itself on "blood and thunder" literature. Except, perhaps, in one regard—the hero does little of "derring-do"—things happen to him, rather than that he, as all heroes from time immemorial do, forces circumstances to his purpose.
Maybe, however, the juvenile critic
*"In Assyrian Tents." By Louis Pendleton. Jewish Publication Society of America.