The Maccabaean · Vol. VII, No. 1 · July 1904
32printed page
scan 34 of 66
32
THE MACCABÆAN
[July 1904]

pride, and in the case of the Maccabaeans, for pure clannishness. Now, whilst violent changes of thought are possible—and no one can deny another's right to such changes of opinion—the least we are entitled to is consistency.

Before Mr. Wolf can take up the apostleship of assimilation, he should release himself from all those Jewish organizations in which a strictly Jewish objective has been the prevailing thought and the guiding spirit. To preach assimilation as the only remedy to Jewish evils, or to advocate a non-futurity as the only good future and to assist and promote organizations which strive to keep various classes from assimilation is to create a perilous position, not for Mr. Wolf but for the Jews in general, whose spokesman may be regarded as speaking with his tongue in his cheek. Mr. Wolf, of course, means no such thing, but it is very difficult to explain such paradoxes to a not too sympathetic world.

In the Commons.

Until the exact phraseology of Hansard reaches us, we cannot say of a surety what the "considerable discussion" in the House of Commons on the East African project really amounts to. The New York Times presents us with an admittedly partial account. It is devoted almost entirely to the observations of Major Evans-Gordon, who had no reputation in England for political sagacity until he uplifted the British Brothers' League, and helped to force into existence the Alien Commission. Whether such politics are wise, and whether his trip to Eastern Europe brought him praise rather than notoriety is an open question. There have never been lacking in the British Parliament

men of breadth of thought as well as of affairs; and with these the issue will ultimately prevail. That the protest of the London Jews, and the deputation headed by Lord Rothschild, practically put an end to the obnoxious anti-alien bill is pretty good proof that there is still some power in that community, and some real willingness to sacrifice for Jewish causes. The Jews in England are fairly united in favor of the East African project; and if they have a mind to make the issue their own —which they seem inclined to do—they will, in all likelihood, prevail.

That the British Government stands by its offer is clear enough. The Secretary for Foreign Affairs has allowed the hot-headed, sport loving Commissioner for the East African Protectorate to resign rather than accept East African advice against Downing Street policy. The Government position seems clear enough. The East African offer means England's real way out of the alien question, its contribution toward the settlement of the Jewish problem, and an answer to Russian and Roumanian brutalities.

But the attitude of the British Government is not one which the Jewish people must necessarily accept. Hospitality by administrative order is not agreeable to us, nor is it a means which, in a free Empire like the British, can succeed. Therefore, all that the cable dispatches tell us of practical value is that Zionism, which so many Jews ignore, has been discussed in the House of Commons; and that English public opinion is in the making on the various issues involved. Agreed, or not agreeing to our views, we admit for our part that something is gained for the Jews when the mother of Parliaments begins to be seriously interested in the broad question of the Jewish future.