The Maccabæan
EDITORIAL PAGES J. DE HAAS, EDITOR
The Seventh Convention.
There are several views possible as to any Convention, and there are very many possible as to such a gathering as the Seventh Zionist Convention held at Cleveland. We have the sweeping view which comes from afar off, from Mrs. Hannah Solomons, who said in London that Zionism was of no account in the United States. That planes our Convention down to a very little thing, indeed. We do not admit the littleness, and do not propose to refute the observation. The demonstration of fact must be within the fact itself, and whenever the Zionist Convention meets in Chicago, we shall note with interest whether Mrs. Solomons repeats her assertion or repents it.
There is a local view of the Convention that which repeated the attitude of the Munich rabbi, and desired to be inhospitable to Zionism. Herr Rudolf Mosse, of the Berlin Tageblatt, once threatened to spend one hundred thousand marks on the destruction of the Zionist movement. We do not know if he spent it; if he did, it availed him little. Some Cleveland gentlemen have by this time probably learnt the futility of such a course.
There is a better local view, that of the observer who came inquisitive and doubtful, and remained to be impressed by the assemblage of one hundred and eighty-eight delegates who could and would demonstrate their enthusiasm for a holy cause. To such the Convention from beginning to end—from the Herzl
pictures in the streets to the “good and welfare” was a revelation of a spirit common enough amongst the mass of the Zionists.
Next, there is the view of the Jew a practical stranger to the movement, slightly antipathetic to it, and who was amazed at points of order, votes, caucuses and the like, expecting a continuous fire of Zionist speeches. There is nothing wrong with that view except that it ignores the object for which the Zionists convene.
And so we come to the delegate’s view, who no longer comes to swell a demonstration, to add that charm of mystery which the visitor from afar off lends to every such gathering. The delegates came to ask for an account of the stewardship of the administration, to legislate for the coming year, and to appoint officers to conduct the business of the movement. This is what “in Convention assembled” means, and must mean at all times; and we believe that delegates found themselves free to exercise opinions, to criticise, to commend and to plan progressive legislation.
When we come to examine the work of the Convention in detail, we find that the legislation has been of extraordinary amplitude.
Palestine, of course, seems to be very little in consideration in such issues; but the power to organize, the development of organization, and the desire to create one great movement and to subject one’s self to it when that organization has Palestine for its object is to have done considerable toward gaining the end sought. We shall have to insist on that in and out of season, for there are round and about us a great mass of Jews who seem to think that when they have given their sympathy to Zionism, they have done their duty. Our Convention demon-
