The Story of the Convention.
Pittsburg won its fame for the enthusiasm it infused into the Zionist body—an enthusiasm, however, free from the frothiness which evaporates and goes stale through its own sparkle and effervescence. It was an enthusiasm that stood the propa- sandists in good stead when vigor was exhausted and nerves jaded; it carried the movement through a year of hard work, and helped to cope with difliculties and surmount obstacles. What these were we need not recount now. We have passed them by; Cleveland has come and gone and the Federation has leapt forward a mighty stride, dominant where once it was immaterial, potent where once it was weak, fearless where once it was timid, respected where once it was sneered at, courted where once it was renulsed.
New responsibilities, graver tasks are now ours; and for these we need what Cleveland has given us—Enthusiasm plus. Especially this plus.
Not that the enthusiasm was lacking; it was all there, suppressed, held in leash, ready to burst forth with magnified intensity as it did at the banquet and during the closing session—but the plus was stronger; the plus of deep earnestness. .
So the Cleveland Convention, detracting nothing from that splendid enthusiastic self-devotion which is the greatest strength of the Zionist movement in America—which has swept it forward to its present splendid position, gave it yet another and equally potent factor—the “earndstness” with which it must take up the tasks which are imposed upon it by virtue of its being “the only movement in this country or elsewhere which makes for positive and uncompromising Jewishness.”
* * *
It was this earnestness which gave the Cleveland Convention an aspect somewhat different from previous Federation Conventions.
In a sense it was a political convention— the first of its kind in the movement. The delegates knew their most important task would be the election of a President. The
secret of Prof. Gottheil’s leave of absence was no secret; avery one knew that for more than three months the council of the Federation had been without the guidance of its chosen chieftain—the man who had led the movement through its “lehryahre” had been compelled to lay down the baton of leadership just at the moment when the movement was entering upon what promises to be a glorious period of its “meister yahre.” And every one knew that much depended on the calibre of Prof. Gottheil’s successor—much depended on him upon whose shoulders the mantle of Elijah would fall. True, some local Councils had voiced their opinions on this grave subject and had given their delegates positive instructions. Other Councils had gone only so far as to pledge their delegates to concerted action, without binding them definitely to any candidate. But, in the main, the delegates were free agents left to the use of their own judgment and discretion.
It seemed at first that there were only two names that had serious consideration, but at the eleventh hour a third name loomed up demanding attention, compelling respect and upsetting all calculations. For between the two the choice would have been easy; the first, Dr. Harry Friedenwald, who had consented to be a candidate at the request of the Executive Council, and on the high ground that to be a Zionist means to be ready to obey at whatever personal sacrifice, and the other, Cyrus L. Sulzberger, who had not only definitely refused the honor, but had declared Dr. Friedenwald a better leader than himself, for whom neverthdless there was to be a deliberate attempt made to stampede the convention. But with the\ third in the field the situation became complicated and trying, indeed. For Gabriel H. Mayer had a certain amount of logie back of his claims upon tke Presidencey— claims dificuit to override, impossible to throw aside. Much, of course, could be said, and finally had to be said, in contravention of these claims, but this was what all wished to avoid, especially those who, with pure minds and clean hands and lofty mo-