Though Labl is an ignorant young man, he is invincible in argument. Wolf purchased the paper, but after glancing at it a few seconds, he remarked:
"I've noticed that you Americans read newspapers because your eyes are blase; you are tired of your disfigured streets, their monotonous regularity, the idiocy of your architecture, the ceaseless panorama of bustle. You have no imagination when you read; you cannot be trusted with facts; everything must be explained in an elementary fashion; you have no standard of value. That is why, when one offers to sell you a newspaper, and you are engaged in conversation, you have no use for it; you prefer the one amusement to the other."
"But with the Jews," he continued, "it is somewhat different. They are indifferent to the printed word in another way. The sacred writings have been closed; and since then, whatever has been written, is looked upon as mere literature, with no bearing on life. They are the greatest critics, but nothing inspires them to action. They may read of the cruellest outrages against their brethren, but it is the technique of the description that appeals to them. Life has become a literary form. And they respond to the appeals of literature with emotional fervor, just as the spectator at the play laughs or weeps as the play demands; but when he considers his conduct between the acts, he chides himself for his unnecessary display of feeling. . . . Your pious Jew bends piously under actual insult, bearing his burden as meekly as if he were a Christian. Your wealthy Jew never feels inspired by the courage of any individual Jew; they who are in a position to be courageous strangely refuse to recognize courage when it is exhibited by a Jew. But both of these types may
weep over a Jewish story, laugh at a Jewish joke, and rejoice when a Jew in fiction shows that he, too, is indeed a man."
"You will admit," I interposed, "that they 'point with pride' whenever the occasion calls for it."
"Yes, that is the melodramatic pose inherited from the centuries of mediaeval persecution. But it is not vital. It is theatricalism with a purpose. It is we, who stand as critics of society, who greet the valorous deeds of those Jews who defend their manhood, with racial exultation and with the joy of men long held in the bondage of oppression, as men 'should greet them. We feel inspired by their examples. We plunge into the arena and become actors too, stimulated by our martyrs. And there is no pious Jew, if only he is poor, who is not proud that the martyr nihilists are Jews, proud that they are their own kin. Yet they dare not confess it openly. And even our wealthy brethren, if only they could rid themselves of the mediaeval dread, even they would find much consolation in the revolutionists of Russia.
"This Russian journal," said Wolf, raising the newspaper, "contains two stories, cautiously told. They are connected in theme, and either of them is worth reading."
"The one item announces the death of a certain young man in the city of Kieff; it is a cold obituary, for it was an ordinary, brutal death. But behind it there looms a sad tragedy.
"For this young man wanted to die for the cause, but something prevented it. For years he had thought that that was to be his destiny, and he felt inspired by the thought that he was to do something that would advance the cause of Liberty in Russia. He was no fanatic,
