The Maccabaean · Vol. VI, No. 6 · June 1904
290printed page
scan 42 of 48
Facsimile · scan 42 of 48
Scan of p. 290
Text · transcribed from the scan

Prof. Graetz and Zionism

BY A. S. WALDSTEIN.

No nation perhaps possesses so many contradictory elements as our people. Weakness and strength, endurance and impatience, self-consciousness and denial of itself, all these are combined in our people in a very palpable degree. And these contradictions are not characteristically ours, but are rather deposits of the peculiar conditions in which we have lived. Our history in the diaspora has been, in great part, one of the tide whose ebb and flow depended upon the power of repulsion and attracton of an outside world. No wonder, therefore, that our ideals have had the unevenness and irregularity of the seabreakers.

This lesson we learn when we read "The History of Hibbath Zion." In this book a record describing in telling details the pre-political Zionist movement down to the Katovitz Conference, there occurs a passage which shows the inconsistency of our people to which I referred above. It was in the eighties of the last century, at the dawn of our people's awakening from its long lethargic sleep, to self-consciousness; when it began to "digest its dreams" of a re-established nationality. The idea did, then as now, take a greater hold upon the minds of our brethren of the East than of those in the West, and if the idea was vague even among the former it was entirely formless among the latter; for in the West it assumed the shape

of a bread-and-butter question, and this not only among the uninitiated, but even among those who were fully aware of the existence of a Jewish nationality, even with a Graetz, who proclaimed this fact historically. For it was to Graetz that the passage in that book refers. Graetz—this record tells us—had at first identified himself with the Hibbath Zion movement, and had become a member of its executive committee; but one fine morning this committee found his resignation on the table simply because it had come to his knowledge that the undercurrent of the movement had been more than charitable, that it had been national. Graetz, heralding to the world the existence of a Jewish nationality, even in the diaspora decrying reformed Judaism because it divests itself from the national garb, and Graetz refusing to work for Jewish nationality, can there be a greater inconsistency! But such inconsistency as this, periodic in our history, is the more exclaimable in the case of Graetz as being characteristic of his time. He lived in a period when the Jewish soul was rent in twain, when nationalism and cosmopolitanism began their long struggle, continuing to our own time; a struggle which will result in a sharp division of the house of Israel, but which raged at that time within the very soul of the individual. Hence the inconsistency of a Graetz, hence also the contortions of many a non-Zionist nationalist of our own day.