The Maccabaean · Vol. VI, No. 5 · May 1904
241printed page
scan 39 of 48
May 1904]
THE MACCABÆAN
241

Zionism in itself presented no difficulty to his mind. In fact, he represented the national idea in the midst of lovers of colonization, and had, long before Dr. Herzl came on the scene, admitted that colonization as colonization, that is, as a philanthrapic movement, could not make much progress. Once, when Sir Samuel Montagu, in the document published in the MACCABAEAN of January, 1903, flew beyond the scope of the movement the Colonel took the setback which it gave him most good naturediy, and he was much more urged to fight for leadership against the new leader than he himself felt called upon to make such a struggle. In fact, Dr. Herzl consulted him while he was still in Cardiff as a military ofhi- cer, organizing the local Jewish congregation, before he consulted anyone else; and Dr. Herzl’s opinion of Goldsmid never varied. Subsequently, Sir Samuel Montagu brought the two men together at his breakfast table; and when, a few days later, Col. Goldsmid was asked ofhcially how he viewed Dr. Herzl’s prospects, he frankly approved them. He never lent a hand to that fight which was waged, not only by the Chovevi Zion of England, but by all the Chovevi Zions against political Zionism. For a time, it is true, he stood on one side. Loyalty to his own organization compelled him to refuse that merging of interests which a wave of enthusiasm dictated. But nothing was nobler in the man than his willingness to be side-tracked, and still offer a word of encouragement to tlıose who went beyond him and used, as it were, his own organization to create a new Zionism. He admired the pugnacity of those who were contending against him, or rather, his organization, and he showed both his strength and his self-control when at that great Conference in London in March, 1898, his organiza-

tion was made subordinate to the general Zionist movement. He described the situation as one in which “the big dog takes shelter under the little dog.” The hero of “Daniel Deronda” no doubt felt that he was the big dog. No doubt he had been it, but when it was beyond dispute that his work had been but a fraction of the whole, he cheerfully gave his assistance; and the writer has still in his possession many a pencilled letter, written in his military manifolding book, advising, suggesting and supporting the movement. All this took place in the early days of the Zionist movement when Herzl was still coming to the front and before the second Congress had given Herzl the real solidity of his leadership.

His soldier's career took him out to Africa, and nothing delighted him more than the hundreds of Zionists, whom he met in the Queen's uniform. When he came back in 1901, with the prospect of retirement before him, his mind was deliberately fixed upon giving active service to the cause. He took part in the dinner given by the Article Club, at which Mr. Zangwill discussed "the Commercial Future of Palestine"; and subsequent to that, took part in a negotiation which had it prospered, there and then might have advanced the movement far beyond its present position. Tenacious as ever, the failure of that particular project did not discourage him. He joined the expedition to El Arish, and note book in hand, studied the situation with all his old precision and love of detail. He came to the Sixth Congress to hear, see and wonder at what had been born of the work which was partly of his own hands. And even in that Congress, with all its complexities, the issue remained to him simple and clear. East Africa was a distinct stepping stone to Palestine, and there was nothing casuistic in his view of it.