Though not without that leaning towards mysticism which somehow pervades certain elements in the British army, and turns so many of its officers into religious hobby riders, his Jewish thought was wholly sane.
In the course of his travels through the East, he had seen all varieties of Jews; and soldierlike, prized those who were fleet of foot, strong of muscle, could ride a horse or shoulder a gun, far more than the carpet rabbis who offered him their sophistry, and the small change of drawing room talk. Though it was a Russian Jew who founded the Chovevi Zion in England, and brought it there from Russia, it was the name of Col. Goldsmid that made of the Whitechapel movement a force; and it was his brains that evolved the scheme of tents, now long folded and put away. He once asserted, in his love for the Hebrew language, that if the Messiah came and could not speak Hebrew with the Sephardic accent, he would not believe he was the Messiah. But when the Reform Congregation to which he belonged wished to diminish its Hebrew and drop the references to Zion from its prayer book, he unhesitatingly withdrew from it, believing, as he said long afterwards, that Abarbanel’s admonition to the Jews of his day, that those who forgot Zion would suffer, would be true of the descendants of that Sanhedrin, which dclared “France est notre Zion.”
Good humor and earnestness were the chief charms of his personality, and with these he held a loving leadership over a mass of Jews in England, from whom he was otherwise estranged by birth, education, breeding and all possible paths of life. Goldsmid speaking on Judas Maccabæus, and outlining the Beth Horon on a black board, was a study eloquent of the man, his manner and thought. Goldsmid
smid on the stump throughout the length and breadth of the land, seeking the creation of a Jewish State sufficiently large at least to give the non-resident Jew a Jewish council of protection, explained the theory of his being; Goldsmid leaving England for the Argentine, with a crowd dragging the horses from his carriage, and he exclaiming, "We begin at A to end at Z," suggested a tenacity of purpose which removed from every mind the possibility of his indulging in sophistry. He believed absolutely and unqualifiedly in the ultimate end, and was willing to build with any material, as long as he perceived that structure would achieve that towards which he was aiming. The twenty months that he spent in the Argentine as administrator of Baron de Hirsch's colonies did not weaken him, though his trials were innumerable, and the necessity for harshness made him unpopular with those who received complaining letters. He believed positively that these Argentine Jewish farmers would return, themselves or in their descendants, to Zion, as the magnet is drawn to the pole. He abhorred the disorganization of Jewish life, and helped in the establishment of the Paris Central Committee of the Chovevi Zion long before the Jewish people were ready for such an international organization. He would enter into the most minute details of a colonization project or inveigle a non-Zionist into remembering Palestine by offering a glass of Palestinian wine, without ever forgetting the broader issue. This was the most remarkable trait in his character, and entitled him not only to a leadership in Jewry while he held it positively, but to that homage he received from Jews all over Europe when he was no longer in official relationship with any organization.
The transition from Choyevi Zion to