The Maccabaean · Vol. VI, No. 5 · May 1904
234printed page
scan 32 of 48
234
THE MACCABÆAN
[May 1904]

crave your indulgence that we may exchange our thoughts."

“Brother of the Faith,” he spoke with measured breath, “Israel was, Israel is, Israel will be! for God has so willed it, but Israel’s future must be as different from Israel’s present, as its present is from its past. To spread Monotheism, to realize the Universal brotherhood of Man, to become the yeast that will leaven the darkened masses,—this is the mission God has given us. To fulfil this mission we must acquaint our Christian neighbors with the great, grand and simple tenets of our faith. We must cast off the strange and superstitious customs and ceremonials that hamper our social life and interfere with the Americanization of our Children.”

Observing the Zionist button in the lapel of my coat, he stopped rather abruptly and began again in changed tone, "We must wipe Jerusalem from our minds, we must eradicate the thought of Zion and remember for once and for all that the notion of Jewish nationality, as you call it, is a foolish dream, a fantastic misconception. We are Jews by religion and have no other bond that unites us." With a show of anger, he snapped his whip, and as he drove quickly away, I turned around for a last glimpse of my enlightened friend of a moment ago, to see him disappear rapidly southward.

Our conversation had been brief but much sharper than I had anticipated. My recent friend and his strenuous views quite puzzled and perplexed me. His faith in the Jewish future was beautiful. His conception of the Jewish Mission was magnificent. His solution of the Jewish problem would certainly do much good, but why so strange an antipathy to Zion? Why so bitter in the mention of Jerusalem? Was it criminal for the Jew to as-

sert his racial and national existence ?

So forcibly had he denied our national and racial existence, asserting only our religious cohesion, that it made me think hard. Do we not quibble over words and fine spun distinctions? To some we are a peculiar “people”; to others a stiff-necked “race,” to still others a strange “nation.” Some look at it as a sociological question, others as a psychological phenomenon, and others still as an anthropological fact. Why pause on the mere play of a word and the skillful turn of a scientific phrase? It should sufhice that we are decidedly peculiar and different from all others, that we have been thus through all our history of 4,000 years. Only among ourselves are we in doubt, only within our own ranks do we charge ourselves with being nothing but a religious sect bound by no other bond than religion.