What, then, is our task as missionaries ? What are we to teach the nations, especially those who carry aloft the banner of western civilization ? We have given them our Bible, our whole religious treasury. It is now theirs as much as ours. It is they, and not us, who are now translating it into the most barbarous tongues, and are carrying it into the remotest and darkest corners of the world. (By the way, when will the Jewish Publication Society publish the long-promised new and improved translation of the Bible for Jewish homes and schools?) There is not a single intelligent Jew who will doubt that, were every American rabbi to go out of his business this very day, ethical monotheism and all it implies would still continue its triumphant march through the civilized world, just as if everv American lew were a rabbi.
Where, then, is the sphere of our peculiar missionary efforts? And the answer is: To do battle for justice, human brotherhood, and against all the forces of Satan, shams, hypocrisies, violence, greed, corruption, the evil influences of money, of scheming and speculating, etc. This is certainly a noble undertaking. But I have always felt that these words have a hollow ring of insincerity when coming from the mouths of rabbis who preach them for all the way from $1,500 to $15,000 a year with perquisites, to congregations composed of brokers, bankers, members of the 'Change, dealers in liquor, tobacco, jewelry, and every thing else, who, the rabbis well know, will no more be influenced by their words than will the Man in the Moon. Ah, if the rabbi were only to adopt the method of the zealous Socialist or misguided Salvationist, and preach these noble truths on the street corners, or in dingy halls, without the prospect of any greater remuneration than the returns of the cir-
culating hat, what a different stamp his gospel would bear! Furthermore, if our mission is to do such battle for the nations among whom we live, is it good policy, is it wisdom, to remain isolated and aloofaloof, rather than combine forces with other groups who are doing, or claiming to do, the same work? Where is the sophist who can make us believe that in union there is not strength but weakness?
This, then, is where the argumentation leads, and the young American rabbi has the choice between holding on to his job because he was trained for it, or stepping down and out and beginning it all over again. And all this is the sad result of the faulty logic of his masters who say that Judaism is only a religion, and as such only it must continue. How different is the deduction to be drawn from our history. Judaism is the beliefs, ideas, hopes and aspirations, and the concomitant practices, in short, the life, physical, intellectual, and spiritual of people, who, though without a political center and national functions, still wished to maintain their national identity, continue their national existence, and looked forward to the day when they should once more be a nation indeed, restored upon their soil. Judaism without its nationalism is simply unthinkable, and every effort to denationalize it must lead to its annihilation. The desire to maintain a national existence may not be as noble an aspiration as to be the missionaries to the Gentiles. But what of that? The first and most natural mission of the individual and the group is to live, and not to court an untimely Nirvana; and as long as there is life there is hope for still greater things than merely to live.
Let us then devote ourselves to this mission first.
