sorber. It is only when we admit that an outside element has absorbed the individual, that we admit that some one, or some phase of life has been assimilated. We claim that Jewish history proves that the Jewish entity in the Jew has always been stronger, more puissant, and more potential than any menace that he may have gathered to himself as a matter of local complexion.
Rabbi Moses endeavors to meet us by asking, "Do Chanukah and Purim have only a Jewish aspect? Did the Hellenization exempt Judea from its scope?" No. The Hellenists endeavored to conquer the mentality of Jerusalem, just as Hellenism endeavored to make itself the culture of Rome. But whereas, say, Pompeii was, at the day of its destruction a magnificent example of the Graeco-Roman cult, Jerusalem was, at the day of its destruction, fiercely, intensely Judaic and Jewish.
Zionism endeavors to see Jewish life as a whole, not in that incomplete, dissevered and scientifically absurd form of separating belief from believer. There was, and there is, an interior as well as an exterior influence amongt the Jews, although, nowadays, in the cult of the mission, so many worship, as it were, the glisten of the Jewish eye, but want to know nothing of what produces even that magnetism. So we decline to look at Jeremiah, whom Dr. Moses quotes, on one side. Jeremiah enunciated the Jewish policy of patriotism towards the state—towards any state in which one lived, a doctrine which no Zionist, to our knowledge, has ever pooh-poohed, Dr. Moses notwithstanding. He enunciated also other doctrines, such as the patriotism of the Jew towards Palestine. So even Philo, whatever he sught, according to Mr. Claude G. Montefiore, would never have realized that he belonged to a religious community, and not to a Jewish nation; and the historical evidence, we maintain, has projected that mode of thought into our own times. In Dr. Moses’ words, “The national hope of Israel sounds as a faint and distant echo,” nor do we wonder at it. But to the ears of some millions, the sound is very far from faint. It is the clearest ringing note in their lives, and such sounds cannot be produced by an artificial stimulant. All that Zionism, in its concrete form, has done from
the philosophic point of view, is that it has brought about a concatenation of the national sounds, so that one not only hears its strike, but hears all its quantities produced in unison and their value recognized.
NOT REACTIONARY
Nor can the Zionist movement be regarded in the light of a reaction, except to those who have leapt the boundaries of normal progress, and have come full pelt upon a jutting rock. To such mentally conscious, there must be a road to escape, and the natural path, or the less dangerous path, is that which leads still further down. All that which modernity has brought to the Jew, the Zionists not only regard as valuable, but use as a medium of national advancement. There is no thought or attitude in Israel which is not so embraced, and the more the movement presses on the more every Jew must eventually recognize that his Jewish nationalism is his sustaining quality. The Zionist can look with some indifference upon the war of ideas proceeding amongst people, because he is sustained by something that stands above the current religious squabble and theological quarrel.
The Ghetto is not a thing of the past. We wish it were. In Eastern Europe it has grown to the girth of a Pale of Settiement. In all the free lands, including the United States, it exists in every city as a natural effect, for the Jew has in him something which he cannot shake off. A passing incident, the resignation of the Archbishop of Olmutz, a baptized Jew, because of anti-Semitic attacks, is perhaps the best proof we could offer Dr. Moses and his like at this juncture to prove that the national quality of the Jew is not only a continuous theory of the past, but a concrete factor of the present.
Every philosopher will determine the philosophy of the nineteenth century Judaism according to his own viewpoint. And to our thinking, that which will tell most in the summary of that century, is that at the end the Jew stood very much where he stood at the beginning; but with added strength resulting from a determination to use that which is within himself towards his ultimate salvation.
