The Maccabaean · Vol. VI, No. 3 · March 1904
120printed page
scan 20 of 48

seth Yisorel and translator of Graetz's history into Hebrew, who was waiting for Baron de Hirsch's answer to a petition presented by the representatives of the Russian Chovevi Zion, which was then at variance with Baron de Rothschild. Rabbi Mohilever and Dr. Hirsch Hildesheimer, were the spokesmen of the Chovevi Zion.

“Although pressed by the Russian Chovevi Zion, through Mr. Rabinowitz and Dr. Hildesheimer, to add my voice to their petition, I refused to do so, stating it as my view that the Palestinian cause must stand or fall with Baron Rothschild ; and that the Chovevi Zion should, therefore, at all events, co-operate with him, whether with or without Baron de Hirsch. I did, however, assist in aiding the London and Parisian Chovevi Zion in bringing about at that time an entente between Barons de Hirsch and Rothschild ; the result of this, I believe at least in part,was thatBaron deHirsch’s answer which was, at first, expected to turn out absolutely in the negative, assumed the form now published for the time here below, from a copy I received from Drs. Sonnenfeld and Schwarzfeld, Baron de Hirsch’e General Agent and Secretary, respectively.

"On the strength of this document, a conference was convened in Paris at the office of the Alliance Israelite Universelle, Rue de Trevise, about the middle of September, 1891, participated in, to the best of my recollection, by Grand Rabbin Zadoc Kahn, M. Erlanger, on the part of Baron de Rothschild, and by M. Isidor Loeb, on the part of Baron de Hirsch, and Rabbi Mohilever, Dr. Hildesheimer, S. P. Rabinowitz, Col. Goldsmid and myself, as representing the Chovevi Zion.

“This conference decided to raise IO,000 francs for the expenses of the Com-

mission referred to in Baron de Hirsch's document. I accompanied Rabbi Mohilever and Dr. Hildesheimer back to London, where we conferred on the matter with the Russo-Jewish Committee at the office of Sir Samuel Montagu and with Lord Rothschild (who was seen by Rabbi Mohilever and Dr. Hildesheimer). The Russo-Jewish Committee donated two hundred pounds sterling for the purpose. During my first stay in Palestine, from the first of Tishri to the middle of Kislev (about beginning of October to the middle of December, 1891, I received information from Dr. Hildesheimer that the 10,000 francs were fast materializing. I also undertook to have duly contributed the sum of $2,000, then deposited by the New York Chovevi Zion with Baron de Rothschild.

"On my return to Paris, end of December, 1891, I was informed by M. Erlanger that the matter had been wholly dropped. The reason of the break down, as far as I could ascertain, was a purely personal one between the two barons."

The memorandum practically speaks for itself. It is clear and insistent upon the facts that Baron de Hirsch was not anti-Palestinian, but was opposed to haphazard settlement; that he personally, which was quite natural, was more in favor of his Argentine scheme; but that if those who addressed him were willing to follow his advice and safeguard the preliminaries, he would support them in the negotiations to be undertaken at Constantinople. We would not claim that he here in any way addresses himself upon the question of the creation of a political state; but what he did believe in, from his own words, was the obtaining of land by political negotiations, and that he favored rather obtaining land by concession than by purchase. He himself did not seem to have thought very much of