sition of his symbols, and yet the symbol itself becomes new and bespeaks a new imagination. He plays with the common Jewish picture, as when he makes a frame of the heads of the Rabbis; he covers the workman with the tarantula
of the sweatshop, turns the sweater into a bloated blood sucking vampire, or offers the pitying angel to the suffering; the man bound in thorns sees the sun rising in the East, and so on through the gamut of Jewish emotion.
Lilien foreshadows the possibilities of a Jewish art. He had nothing to do with the common life—his artistic consciousness is not personal; only the method is peculiar to himself, and even when he is designing a book plate he is consciously giving expression to Jewish feeling. Psychologically it might be said that if there is a Jewish art, Lilien expresses it; his is the work of the complex Jew—but that same expression will not be permanent—for after all, the temperament of Lilien and those who are follow-
ing in his wake is that of the Ghetto and immediately after. His very work aims at helping the people to realize that the future is not to be black misery, but lightness and joy; that the future environment is to be the meadow and not the city; and thus, whilst acknowledging the unique service that Lilien and his co-workers are rendering the Jews, we are bound to conclude that their expression of Jewish art must be transient, and that the Jewish art that is to be will bring us a new thought, one that we only grope at to-day; the Jew remaining Jew, but the impress of the Ghetto removed from brain, physique and lineament. Many are de-Ghettoized but none are un-Ghettoized; and the Ghetto is an enforced and not a natural environment of the Jew. The Jewish art school cannot, of course, go beyond what it knows, and the Hebraic temperament, blended by Hellenism, to which we look forward, is a mystery of the future. In our present Lilien is, and to the future will be, an artistic genius of our age, doing in
black and white drawing what Halevy did in song in Spain of old; he is depicting the sorrows, sufferings, hopes and yearnings of Israel, and this genius of our day deserves the laurel of our unstinted admiration.