The Maccabaean · Vol. VI, No. 2 · February 1904
43scan
of 54
Facsimile · scan 43 of 54
Scan of scan 43
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Maccabæan

EDITORIAL PAGES

J. DE HAAS, EDITOR

ALARUMS AND EXCURSIONS.

We publish elsewhere in this issue the details of the resolutions which together make up the ultimatum of some of the Russian leaders to Dr. Herzl. Being at a convenient distance, we can regard these matters somewhat more cool-headedly than those of our friends who are in Europe, and who have issued the cry, "Zionist Crisis."

Du 5 Es We admitted in the last issue of the MaccABAEAN that the situation is critical, but we confess that we note with satisfaction that our anti-Zionistic friends have not siezed upon this passing storm to hurl at us cries of “Split,” “Division,” and the like. They have at least learned that a movement like the Zionist is not easily broken; time was when we undoubtedly feared such politics, and when every Zionist deemed it wise to whisper his difference of opinion. We have outgrown that; and we can, if we are so minded, freely castigate our Russian co-workers who have started this rebellion, without fear of serious consequences to the movement as a whole. The enormous number of protests from Russia prove definiteiy that the conveners of the Charkoff conference had no mandate; and in fact, that they have presented an ultimatum largely because they were misled into believing that the Russian-Hebrew press, which stands very closely in with them, represents the opinions of the masses of Russian Jews. But the Russian-Hebrew journals have made their own excitement, no doubt to the amazement of the people who have declined to get excited, otherwise than as earnest protestants against Dr. Kohan-Bernstein and his collagues.

A large number of observers view the situation as one in which the real bone of contention is the leadership of the movement, and that the East African project has simply served to bring to a head the elements antagonistic to the present leadership. As there is no one in the movement who could replace Dr. Herzl, the individual claims to leadership are egotis-

tic nonsense. If we are not peevish and fearful as to this storm raised by the Russian members of the Greater Actions Comite, we are not, at the same time, blind adherents to Dr. Herzl and the “Herzlian” policy. Our leader has perhaps committed as many errors as any other man in a like position. But he has accomplished more things than any other man who has held a similar position could have accomplished in the same space of time; and that, after all, is the real question. So we rest content in the feeling that whatever claims may be put forward, whatever vain thoughts have been bred in idle hours, the next Congress will put a speedy and complete stop to them.

We believe we are presenting the Zionist view in America if we say, however, that it is very far from our belief that the men who have raised this revolution should, for that reason, be forced out of the movement. They have their faults and they have blundered horribly. They acted stupidly.

When we, however, say that we do not wish to see these men ousted from the movement, we do so because we believe that they will accept the lesson of their defeat, and as strong men, continue the work in the old right and honest way. Men are to be forgiven if, for a moment, "vaulting ambition o'er leaping itself" suggests so high a position as the leadership of the movement confers to-day as any Jew; and the dizzy descent is in itself sufficient punishment to the minds of those who do not seek vengeance. The other side to this crisis, that of presenting an ultimatum, attempting to throttle the free speech of the movement, playing at a combined autocracy to offset individual autocracy deserves the severest reproval. By such action Dr. Kohan-Bernstein and his colleagues have set the worst possible example that ever could be set to a mass of people still untrained in the ways of political life. Were Dr. Herzl to yield to-day for a moment, the post would contain nothing but ultimatums from every disgruntled member of an organization, who is determined to force the position of those in superior office. Looked at from a practical point of view, this is a question of Zionistic politics necessary to the evolution of the still incomplete constitution of our movement.

The lesson swift and sharp is that the organisations for their common good refuse to follow a disruptive lead—that lesson is suffi-