The Maccabaean · Vol. VI, No. 2 · February 1904
86printed page
scan 36 of 54
86
THE MACCABAEAN.
[February 1904]

are worse than conditions in other large Jewish communities in the United States, only in proportion to population. The same problems that confront New York, confront Chicago, Boston, Philadelphia, and even the smaller communities.

If our Jewish boys are to be saved to Judaism and American citizenship, we must first ascertain the cause of the present evil conditions, and devise a remedy. The cause in one community is the cause in all communities, and the remedy in one is the remedy in all.

At bottom, all of the evils which beset American Jewry is the loss of that spiritual foundation upon which the structure of his education has been reared for so many centuries past. Whatever else the Jew lacked through the countless years of persecution, he did not lack instruction in the Word of God, and this carried him safely through all the forms of oppression to which he was subjected.

With the realization of religious freedom, in this country, he has turned his thoughts in other directions, and religion, once foremost in his mind, has become a last consideration. There may be ample excuse for this; doubtless, the problem of "bread and butter" has been most pressing. But the consequences have been dire, and direst of all for the Jewish boy who has been bereft of spiritual guidance.

It is very true that attempts have been made to supply this spiritual guidance, but the summing up of the results of these attempts may be written down in one word: "Failure." In a report to the Executive Council of the Federation of American Zionists in October last, on this very subject I wrote:

"Without the slightest desire to criticise the methods in vogue, in either the private schools (Chedarim) or public

schools (Talmud Torahs, religious classes, etc.) it must be said that even if the pedagogic methods were perfect, there is very little to attract the Jewish youth of America, and particularly the growing boys, to these public or private schools. At its very best, the Jewish education of the Jewish youth, in this country, inflicts a considerable amount of hardship upon the youth. Attendance at any of these schools means the deprivation of the right of the boy (we are dealing here with the boy exclusively) to have a certain part of the day for recreation. That this right is inherent—that the recognition of this inherent right is essential in any successful educational curriculum is too well established to permit of any discussion. * * * * Even more important is the recognition of this right, when we have before us the unalterable fact that Jewish education for the youth of this country must be given, and partaken of, after the closing of the sessions of the general schools, when the youthful mind has already become wearied with the work in these schools, and the youthful body craves the stimulus of healthy, normal, youthful exercise."

(This much must be taken for granted: that religious instruction should be given after school hours; that if we are to preserve the spirit of American religious liberty, we must resist to the uttermost the scheme to make religion a part of the public school curriculum. That day when religion will be taught in the public schools, the spirit of religious freedom will become a pleasant fiction.)

Continuing the report I said:

"Very naturally, education (even with the best pedagogic methods) becomes very difficult under such circumstances. Add to the rebellious attitude of the boy's