Patriotism and Zionism.
By Cyrus L. Sulzberger.
PATRIOTISM is the crowning argument of the anti-Zionist. "How can you," he says, "give to your country that single-hearted devotion to which she is entitled if your mind is engaged with the thought of Zion?" This might be a valid objection if a fair definition of patriotism involved an exclusive attitude, such as is here indicated. Patriotism, according to the Century Dictionary, is "the passion which moves a person to serve his country either in defending it from invasion or in protecting its rights and maintaining its laws and institutions." That the Zionist doctrine is not at variance with the demands of patriotism is evidenced by the American attitude towards Cuba, which affords an instance more nearly parallel than history usually furnishes. In order to secure to the people of Cuba a publicly legally-assured home in Cuba the people of the United States, through the national conventions of their political parties, through their representatives in Congress and through the mouth of the President, urged upon the Spanish monarch their interest in the Cuban situation and their desire to see that situation alleviated. When finally it was deemed that patience was no longer a virtue the American Congress, sustained by substantially the unanimous sentiment of the American people, declared that Cuba is and of right ought to be free and independent, and upon that declaration war was made upon Spain and the independence of Cuba established.
Surely if ever there was a reply to the doctrine that patriotism involves exclusiveness here it is. Would anyone dare say that they were not patriotic men
who made the declaration as to Cuba’s freedom and independence, and who followed up their declaration by the supreme test of war? And if it was patriotic to go to war in behalf of the republic of Cuba, how can it be unpatriotic to make peaceable and purely moral propaganda in behalf of the state of Judea? It is conceivable that the argument may be made thus: “But you are interested in your own people in the Zionist movement whereas in the American movement for Cuba we were interested in an alien people; therefore yours is a selfish while ours was an unselfish movement.” As a matter of fact, the American movement in behalf of Cuba was not and did not purport to be an unselfish movement. On the contrary, the repeated basis of our activity was the commercial and financial interests of our citizens. But assuming for argument’s sake that it had been otherwise and that the attitude of the United States had been taken solely on the grounds of the intolerable conditions prevailing with reference to the Cubans themselves, the application of the argument would then result in this: that an American not related to Cuba might patriotically interest himself in securing the establishment of the Cuban republic, but an American of Cuban extraction doing the same thing would be unpatriotic. It is a reductio ad absurdum. Or, to apply it to Zionism, a Jew who is a Zionist is unpatriotic because he is interested in establishing a political home elsewhere for his own people, but the non-Jews who are Zionist are not unpatriotic because the people for whom this home is to be established is not their own people. Reduced to writ-