force of principle behind it as it did in idolatrous times, or when the same alternative presented itself to the Jews in the Crusades. The unity of God—the central doctrine of Judaism— was even as much the leading article of faith in Mohammedanism. Already in similar circumstances and in much earlier times authoritative Jewish opinion had limited the duty of martyrdom to the commission of either one of these capital offences—idolatry, unchastity and murder. The acceptance of the Moslem formula did not come within this category of prohibited acts, and, therefore, many Jews found it easy in that age of religious persecution to accept Islam as the price of their life and liberty. It also helps to explain how it happened that Jewish public opinion could regard such apostacy as involving no disgrace. But the higher and more delicate conscience of a man like Maimon and his son, Moses, must have rankled deeply under a form of compromise clearly casnistic and expedient. Maimon’s Letter was written to meet the danger which such an attitude would be likely to impose on its adherents. In part it was a defence, a somewhat veiled justifhication of the conduct of these pseudo converts, but its main purport was to exhort to a firmer faith in God’s unalterable purposes. Maimon argues, “that Israel’s tribulations were .chastisement of love, the tender correction administered by a father to his wayward child. No Israelite should imagine that God had changed his plan, that Israel his beloved son is now cast off for another. God does not desire a thing and then dispise it. He does not favor and then reject.” He then makes a stronger appeal on the basis of God’s promises to Israel, which, like the Law itself, are of eternal and irresistible validity “We must no more doubt
God's promises than we doubt his existence." He urges his brethren to a whole-hearted loyalty to their God. "What health can there be for him who is not whole with his master." The Law of God was a cord stretched from earth to heaven, a sure rescue for those who, immersed in the sea of captivity, grasped at this unbreakable means of safety. Then with noble charity towards those of his brethren who had lost firm hold of the Lord, Maimon said: "He who clings to it with his whole hand has doubtless more hope than he who clings to it with but part of it, but he who clings on with the tips of his fingers has more hope than he who lets go of it altogether." Coming from a foremost champion of a 'legalistic' religion, this is one of the finest expressions of tolerance which mediaeval literature can show."
The son was much more outspoken on the question than the father. The latter applied the principle of faith to the question of pretended apostacy; the son merely applied the principle of law. Maimonides judged from a severely legal standpoint. He himself might adopt an ideal standard of conduct, but as an upright judge he would require no more than the letter of the law. And the letter of the law as we have seen did not require the supreme sacrifices in the case of the Moslem formula. "Indeed, any Jew," said Maimonides, "who after uttering the Moslem formula, 'There is no God but Allah and Mohammed is the prophet of Allah,' wishes to observe the whole 613 precepts in the privacy of his home, may do so without hindrance. Nevertheless, if even under these circumstances a Jew surrenders his life for the sanctification of the name of God, he has done nobly and well, and his reward is great before the Lord. But if a man asks me: Shall
