the economic effect upon the non-Jew, upon which Mr. White lays the greatest stress. No Zionist can object, rather would we welcome a conference of the Powers, were the initiative to be taken by Russia, an act almost too wild to imagine at this juncture of the political situation, or by England or by the President of the United States.
Such a conference could do no harm, but would in the end be productive of good, if only as an acknowledgment of responsibility and an admission of the unrighteousness or the ordinary treatment meted out to the Jewish people. We would hail with delight the day on which either Downing Street or Washington took such a measure, but the probabilities are not great.
And beyond that, we part company with Mr. Arnold White even when he calls on Christendom to help Russia "in her holy mission of settling the Jewish question on lines of humanity and justice, and otherwise to benefit the race to which the founder of Christianity belonged." The present position of the Jews in Russia is that of struggle, but at least they have the right of regarding their bad treatment as justifying their struggle, the desire for removal from Russia and the basis of their claim for help upon the rest of the world. Their lot would be far worse if they were silenced by being compelled thereto out of a sense of gratitude, after Russia had extended their places of settlement, by giving them an inch where they need an ell, and where the bureaucracy, civil and religious, was still treating them, within the limits of that extra inch, in the old inhuman fashion. Mr. White does not realize the paradox when in one breath he reminds the Czar that Kishineffs are not
in accord with twentieth century civilization, and in the other, casts a halo over Russia if she take up the Jewish question on a new basis. In this, as in many other things, we feel to-day, and will continue to feel for a long time to come, that "Scratch a Russian and you will find a Tartar."
Unquestionably, the whole world is entitled and should take part in the solution of the Jewish problem. This is what Zionism claims, but the Jew himself is also entitled to express his opinion as to what he wants and what he wishes; and, on the whole, we believe that he is a better authority on that point than Mr. Arnold White. Last summer, M. von Plehve, for the Russian Government, offered, in the anxiety of his desire that the Jews should get out, to help Zionist negotiations in Constantinople. If Mr. White is sincere in what he seeks to accomplish, and if he has the power which he hints at, he would earn the eternal gratitude of the Jews, who are the most concerned, by helping to get that lever in motion.
In addressing the Czar he rather untruthfully says, "Wherever there is a Jew, there Russia has an enemy." It is not quite so bad as that; though in the process of time it may become so. At least, we have at present no reason to love Russia. Some fear, and some hate her, and the vast majority have such limited confidence in the Czar's power to help the Jewish people, or in the official desire to treat the Jews otherwise than as dogs, that they wish to sever their connection with Russia as soon as possible. Notwithstanding that he loves the country, notwithstanding that he is loyal, it is good for the Jew if he leaves the territory of the White Czar. The hug of the bear, even at its friend-
