The Maccabaean · Vol. VI, No. 1 · January 1904
39printed page
scan 41 of 54
January, 1904.]
THE MACCABÆAN.
20

hind him except the evolution of religious ideas, and these have bent with the violent storms that have beset the long road of the Jewish travail. The Jew is not essentially a paradox, but a jumble of centuries would be a mass

of paradoxes, inconsistencies, and what the literary critics and the dressmakers call "loose ends." This jumble are the several generations that, knit together, make the Jewish world.

Dr. Herzl and the East African Project

The following letter was recently sent by Dr. Herzl to Sir Francis Montefiore, Bart., president of the English Zionist Federation:

9 Turkenstrasse, 1,VIENNA, 14th December, 1903.

DEAR SIR FRANCIS: You have expressed to me in your letter to hand a desire that I should give you some information in respect to the East African project.

Let me, however, first of all, make my position clear. Ever since the last Congress the wildest statements have been freely indulged in, attaching to me a desire to divert our movement away from the Holy Land, and to direct it to East Africa. Nothing could be further from the truth. As I said at the last Congress, I am a Zionist convinced that the settlement of our People’s Question can only be effected in that country, Palestine, with which are indelibly associated the historic and sentimental bias of its national existence ®No place on earth could therefore, in my mind, supplant or take the place which Palestine holds as the object for which we are striving.

But the British Government having, in terms of singular generosity and consideration, proposed to us the offer of an autonomous settlement, it was surely not possible in reason to do otherwise than extend to such offer our most careful thought.

To my mind four elements were necessary for our deeming within the

range of practical politics the suggestion of the British Government: (1) The territory had to be sufficiently extensive to admit of an immigration of such a character as should be eventually a material relief to the pressure which to-day exists in Eastern Jewry. (2) It follows that the territory had to be one which was colonizable by such people as ours. (3) The concession had to be invested with such autonomous rights as should have ensured the Jewish character of the settlement; and (4) perhaps governing all —the enthusiasm of our own people in respect to the offer had to be of such a nature as would overcome all the obvious difhculties which under most favorable conditions would be bound to arise in the creation of the settlement. j

It must be quite clear, as you point out, that the fourth condition has been, to some extent, absent. Of this I am neither surprised nor do I complain. My connection with our great movement has not left me unconscious of the deep, and abiding love which animates our people for Palestine. While it was my duty to submit to our movement the British suggestion of a refuge —while, in view of Kishineff, I surely should not have been justified in excluding from our people all chance of accepting the suggestion—it is with no small satisfaction that I note that the strongest opposition to the scheme, the strongest note urging me to keep our minds steadily fixed upon Palestine only,