of the Jewish people during the assimilation era has shown how great can be the hope of the future. As little justified as the first is the other charge that the Zionist scheme is too inadequate a fulfillment for the prophet's prediction of the coming Jewish glory. This view shows a singular lack of tone conception both of Zionism and the Prophets. Who could not discern the disproportion between the key in which the noble words of Isaiah is pitched and the extremely humble beginnings of the second Jewish State which this prophet heralded. We may fully surmise that at the time of Ezra and Nehemiah there were dire predictions foretelling the most serious consequences to the valiant little band which went to rebuild the walls of Jerusalem, an attempt which only excited the derision of the Jews' enemies, the Samaritans: "What to these feeble Jews? Will they fortify themselves? Will they sacrifice? Will they make an end in a day? Will they revive the stones out of the heaps of the rubbish which are buried?" (Nehemiah IV, 2.) Such were at that time, and such are now, the criticisms of wise observers. Nevertheless, the work was carried on, though under the most unfavorable circumstances, with a trowel in one hand and a sword in the other, and so poor in material means were these men that the patriot Nehemiah closes the narrative of his work with the touching appeal to the Lord to remember him for good for the due provision of "the wood offering at times appointed." Yet we know that the new Jewish State, whose gradual repopulation was permitted by the grace of an Asiatic conqueror, withstood the storm of centuries amid the conflict of the most powerful empires of antiquity. It was, in fact, the same State whose destruction by Titus has been the unceasing theme of Jewish lamentation. The desire of those who now long for the return of the captivity of Zion would probably be reproduced to the position of affairs depicted in the following words of Philo the Jew, writing at almost the end of Jewish independence: "For no one country can contain the whole Jewish nation by reason of its populousness; on which account they frequent all the most prosperous and fertile countries in Europe and Asia whether islands or continents; looking indeed upon the Holy City as their metropolis in which is erected the sacred Temple of the Most High God, but accounting those regions which have been occupied by their fathers and grandfathers and great-grandfathers and still more remote ancestors, in which they have been born and brought up, as their country." (Philo, Against Flaccus.) It need not be presumed that the success of the Zionist endeavors would absolutely solve the Jewish Question, for it seems to me that there could be no Jewish Mission without a Jewish Question, and all that can be done is to reduce the shadow and increase the light. The anxiety that the existence of a Jewish principality under the suzerainty of the Porte might unfavorably affect the position of the Jews in the Diaspora, loses its point when it is remembered that the privileges of Jewish citizenship are not based on territorial or racial rights, but are determined by utilitarian motives. When under the stress of persecution, Jews have as much justification in leaving the country of their birth as the French Huguenots, the English Puritans, or the German fugitives in 1848. In conclusion it must be said that even if Zionism should for the present not be able to carry out its ultimate object (a contingency which, in view of the difficulties involved, might be quite anticipated), the movement has not only its great moral potentialities, but would represent the organization of the Jewish people, and of its aspirations, the material agency which would at the proper times always be ready to put forth the claim of Israel to its historic land.
The question may, however, be raised: What is to be the position of those who, Nationalist by conviction, do not see eye to eye with the organization which is the expression of the great body of Nationalist opinion? It must first be remembered that in that organization all phases of Nationalist thought can be represented. Not only this, but the Jews placed beyond the reach of immediate oppression have a duty to fulfil to their less fortunate kinsman, and if not to these, at least to themselves or their descendants, who will certainly be seriously affected by the repeated opnings of the floodgates of the Jewish reservoirs of population —a danger which Zionism would largely ward off by diverting the stream to the unexplored, but highly promising, Orient. But there is also to be remembered the judgment passed by history on the acts of men. The Song of Deborah is a noble hymn on "the avenging of Israel when the people willingly offered themselves." But there are in the song fine satirical allusions to those princes and scribes who remained at home to hear the bleatings of the flocks because "they were great