the oppression of a crushing majority. What is the Jew in Austria to do when, to all appearances a German, he is scorned by his co-nationalists and hated by opponents? How is a Russian Jew to become thoroughly Russian if his attendance at a Russian school is limited to a small percentage or prohibited altogether? How is the Jew in Roumania to merge into the mass of his fellow-countrymen if he is completely debarred from a Roumanian educational institution and legally treated as a dangerous foreigner? These facts are well known, but they are not necessarily justly appreciated in all their bearings. It is sufficient to know that for the present purpose, that if it requires two to pick a quarrel, it also requires a good neighbor to be able to keep the peace. The emancipation of the Jews does not merely depend upon themselves, but also upon their surroundings, their hosts or masters. If these are imbued with the stupidity of anti-Semitism, then even the gods must fight for the Jews in vain.
It is evident that the remedy of assimilation is either impossible of application or futile. In this connection it must be borne in mind that in the case of the majority of the Jewish race it is under the iron heel of a rule, whose statesmanship in regard to the Jews consists in having, according to the scheme of Pobiedonostzev, a third of them converted to Christianity, a third expelled from the country and a third starved. It must never be overlooked that the center of gravity of the Jewish tragedy lies in Russia, with six millions of Jews vegetating there, and not, I say, in the British Empire, where there is a smaller Jewish population than that to be found in the single city of Warsaw. What, under the circumstances, is the practical attempt toward a Jewish solution of the difficulty?
Jewish history has again repeated itself and the dying era of assimilation has given birth to a new epoch. With the collapse of the assimilatory movement there arose gradually in the people a longing for self-help, for freedom from the galling yoke of the everlasting Goliath. The times have changed, and the Jews, more particularly the Russian Jews, have changed with them. They have, to a large extent, lost the simple faith which has carried them through many centuries of suffering, and they do not any more regard their future from an apocalyptic point of view. The Russian Jews have become impregnated with the ideas governing the European struggle for freedom, indeed, the educated classes are imbued with the most advanced notions, but the energies generated thereby can, under the circumstances, find no outlet, as in the case of Russian Christians, in professional or official careers. Any hopes of the Jews on the possible advent of a liberal era in Russia must be pronounced chimerical, when it is remembered that, as in Roumania, the Jew would pass from under the present rule of autocracy to that of an intellectual proletariat and hungry politicians. The Russian Jew is thus condemned to lead a hand-to-mouth existence.
At this stage of Jewish history, when in all parts of the world there has taken place a powerful expansion of Jewish energy with a correspondingly strong contraction of the field of activity, there occurred a consolidation of the Jewish people, unprecedented since the loss of their national independence. As the beneficent Zeitgeist at the end of the eighteenth century made assimilation an irresistible force, so nationalism became, at the end of the nineteenth century, the only desirable tendency in Judaism. The Ghetto did indeed, for a long time, prevail against assimilation, not to mention the very many in eastern Europe and Asia who are still antagonistic to it at the present day, but those sections of Jews who have persisted in their opposition have dropped out of the train of Jewish progress and are now only pitiful stragglers. Those also who now, for one reason or another, refuse to follow the present inevitable trend of Jewish life and thought, will share the fate of those who, whatever their motives, are blind to the manifest signs of the times. We may, for instance, notice the same phenomenon in English national aspirations. The same ideas which once proved the glory of English foreign policy have now been totally discarded by the English people for others more in consonance with present-day requirements, with their wider outlook, if greater responsibilities. Whatever we may think, however, of English or other national aggressions, Jewish nationalism is nothing but the expression of the desire of the Jewish people for life and to live its own life. This is merely similar to the struggle for freedom of any other oppressed section of the European population—whether it be national, as that of the Balkans, or social, like that of the working classes. The former have, in the course of the last century, experienced a na-