The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 6 · December 1903
367printed page
scan 36 of 63

mate the real position of the Jews in the present age and their prospects by striking a balance between the undoubted benefits and the still more certain failures attendant upon that which has been the Jewish policy for over a century now.

The general opposition to this policy has come from the antipathy towards the Jews, which is now euphemistically called anti-Semitism—a blind hatred of the Jews which baffles all attempts at enlightenment, because at the bottom there lies the instinctive animal struggle for sustenance. Börne has well described the tone inwardness of this ill-feeling by telling the Jew-baiters of his time: "Ihr hasst nicht die Inden weil sie es verdienen, sondern nur weil sie verdienen." It does not matter how much the Jew verdient: he appears as a competitor of the Whitechapel costermonger in the present anti-alien agitation in England, or in the rôle of the successful Jewish financier Gundermann opposing the ambitious Christian speculator Saccard, so graphically depicted in Zola's L'Argent—whatever the position of the Jew may be, he is in the way.

This fact has been brought home to the Jews in many ways, but it required nothing less than a catastrophe to force the whole matter into the front. Whatever anti-Semitism in western Europe may have attempted against the Jews, nothing has so far gone further than abuse, boycott and a periodical ritual murder affair in Austria and Germany. The rude awakening came from Russia, practically the modern home of the Jewish people, where the murder, outrage and plunder committed on hundreds of thousands of their brethren shook the whole race out of a fairly pleasant dream.

Upon awakening, the Jewish situation presented itself to the modern Ezekiel as to him of old, in the vision of a field of very dry bones. Now, however, there were prophets and priests in Israel who were devising means to revive these bones by the process of assimilation, which had indeed already gained so much ground, not least in Russia itself, but had failed so lamentably there. The idea in those influential quarters was that all that was required was for the Jew to abandon his exclusiveness and to heartily embrace his Gentile fellowman; to acknowledge him as a brother, who was lost in a moment of misconception, but was now to be eternally reunited in fraternal affection. This happy reconciliation, in varying degrees of warmth, has been advocated in season and out of season, and it would perhaps have served as an excellent means of bringing peace—though, perhaps, the peace of death—to the long-suffering Jews if their brethren among other nations had not been so demonstratively unwilling to join in this Jewish manifestation of goodwill. The Jews themselves are, at any rate, convinced that they have made an earnest attempt, and even sacrificed their inner convictions, to merge as completely as possible into the mass of their fellow-citizens, but there honest efforts have been spurned with contempt.

The tragedy of Israel, in which the Jewish prophets and poets have been used by a benefited world as weapons against their own people, that black ingratitude is also evidenced in the social and political fields. Scientific effort, based on far-fetched, paradoxical speculations, have even been made by Aryans to show their superiority over the Semites, and practical politicians have thus been enabled to cover their antipathy toward the Jews with a scientific cloak. Short of apostasy from their ancestral religion (as if that were necessary!) the German Jews have done everything to serve their native country. They have helped proportionately more than any other class of people, to weld the new Empire together. Whatever may be said against this statement, the Jewish conscience is clear on the point. The Jew is loyal, and in countries where he is deliberately denied his right, he is almost unreasonably so. Lately I rad a description how a German-Jewish Teachers' Society concluded a meeting by singing "Deutschland, Deutschland über Alles" with the greatest enthusiasm. This was done by men who, with whatever high qualifications, are, in defiance of their legal rights, openly refused a position in a state school. Yet their enthusiasm was, no doubt, absolutely sincere, for the German Jew, born and bred in the country, is completely German in culture, sentiment and ideal. And Germany ranks among those countries where the Jewish position is secure and favorable in comparison with that existing in countries like Russia or Roumania, where they are at the arbitrary mercy of a tchniovnik or demagogue. Even in Austria, where the Jews possess all rights on paper, they are, although a numerous and even wealthy body, helplessly exposed to