The Maccabaean · Vol. V, No. 6 · December 1903
363printed page
scan 32 of 63
December, 1903.]
THE MACCABÆAN.
363

Israel arguing; that is how we know they do argue. Is the reasoning so fallacious from their point of view?

But whether we agree with that view, or dissent from it, let us, in all fairness, give credit to the Zionist Movement for what it has already achieved. It has infused hope into thousands of homesteads which would otherwise be plunged in despair; it has furnished ideals to a community too much ab-

sorbed in the pursuit of materialism; it has been a consolidating force in Jewry, rallying to the standard of the Faith many whose defection we might have had to lament; it has raised the Jewish Question to a position of prominence in which it has become a factor to be reckoned with in the politics of nations. If it has achieved so much in the face of strenuous opposition, what might it not attain to if it had a united Israel at its back?

Canadian Zionists and East Africa

The Great Hall of the Hirsch Institute at Montreal was recently packed to the very doors by a surging mass of Zionists who, amid the frequent and stirring outbursts of enthusiasm, passed resolutions in support of Great Britain's offer of an autonomous colony in East Africa, and voted confidence in their leaders. The note of loyalty and gratitude to Great Britain also rang out strong and clear throughout the proceedings. Rarely has there been witnessed in Canadian Jewry a more enthusiastic, crowded and representative gathering. Not alone did the Jews of Montreal turn out in overwhelming force, but quite a few came from other parts of Canada to add their voices to the general chorus in support of the action of the Sixth Congress.

The chair was occupied by Mr. Clarence I. de Sola, the president of the Federation of Zionist Societies of Canada, and on the platform were representative men and women, leaders of Zionism, from every part of Canada. The Jewish clergy were also en evidence.

The meeting had been organized with the object of eliciting a free expression of opinion regarding the action of the Sixth Zionist Congress in reference to East Africa.

Mr. Clarence I. de Sola delivered the opening address, in which he exhaustively reviewed the pros and cons of the British East African proposal, and as he made point after point in favor of the action of the Congress the vast assemblage became worked up to a pitch of enthusiasm that found expression in frequent outbursts of applause. He pointed out that the question was not one of choice

between Palestine and East Africa, but that it was clearly and solely a question of choice between East Africa or America. So far as Palestine was concerned, it would remain the chief objective of their movement until they had become repossessed of it. Nothing in the world would ever induce them to abandon their efforts in that direction. They would be traitors to their cause, and unworthy of their confidence if they for a moment slackened their efforts to regain the Holy Land. But they knew very well that it would probably take some time yet before a charter to the Holy Land would be secured. Dr. Herzl and the other leaders of the movement would not leave a stone unturned to hasten the movement when they would be free to carry out their plans in Palestine, but what were they to do while they were waiting for their charter to that land? Were they to be satisfied to fold their arms and allow their brethren to be slaughtered in Russia while they were waiting for the gates of Zion to be thrown open to them, or were they to do something that would in the meantime prevent the repetition of Kischineff and Gomel? He could not understand how anyone could have any doubt as to what answer should be given to such a question. The question, he reiterated, was not at present one of choice between Palestine and East Africa; it was purely a question of choice between East Africa and America. If they were going to live in East Africa under the same conditions as in America he would naturally favor the latter, but this was not the case. The conditions under which they would live in East Africa would be vastly